Joelle-harvey-headshot2010 * Notes * 
Carlos Kalmar is currently conducting San Francisco Symphony in a program of Schnittke's Moz-Art à la Haydn, Haydn's Symphony No. 97, and Orff's Carmina burana. Last night's performance commenced with the amusing piece by Schnittke, scored for 13 strings and conductor, the ensemble was clear and incisive. The two violin soloists, Alexander Barantschik and Dan Nobuhiko Smiley, were especially good. Likewise, the Haydn was played with a pleasing lightness, with fine contrasts of dynamics and tempi. The rather silly Carmina burana was also played and sung beautifully. The brass was, however, not very pretty during "Veris leta facies." The San Francisco Symphony Chorus, the Pacific Boychoir, and the Crowden School Allegro Chorus all sounded lovely. Both the tenor and the baritone soloists, Nicholas Phan and Keith Phares, sang with animation. Joélle Harvey (pictured, photograph by Arielle Doneson) glistened as the soprano soloist. Her bright, flexible sound was the highlight of Orff's piece.

* Tattling * 
The Carmina burana Laser Lightshow Appreciation Society attended this event, and were seated in the very last row of Davies Hall. There was talking from the elderly people in Row J Seats 2-10, and a watch alarm sounded from this area during "Dies, nox et omnia." An exceedingly bored child was sitting in Row H Seat 10, he checked his mobile phone many times, talked, left for the Haydn, and became annoyed when he was told he could not leave during the Orff by the person who brought him.
I too had the most terrible time taking Carmina burana seriously, the music simply made me laugh, and it was difficult to not disturb some around me.

Posted in , ,

4 responses to “Carlos Kalmar & Joélle Harvey at SFS”

  1. sfmike Avatar

    So happy to hear that Joélle Harvey did well. She was Zerlina in that Merolini “Don Giovanni” at Cowell Theatre a couple of years ago, and though I loved her voice, wasn’t sure it would be big enough for Davies Hall which can be really unkind on singers. Glad to hear that was not the case.
    And “Carmina Burana” gives me the giggles too, which is why I won’t be attending.

    Like

  2. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I would love to hear Joélle Harvey in a Händel opera.
    It is wise of you not to attend, though the conducting was impressive.

    Like

  3. patty Avatar

    When I was in high school I thought Carmina Burana was the Best Piece Ever.
    I’m not in high school any more. 😉

    Like

  4. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I was very surprised how well it was performed, but would not normally go to hear this particular piece.

    Like

Leave a comment