OfficeTrio * Notes *
The opening performance of San Francisco Opera’s The Makropulos Case was spectacular. The co-production with Finnish National Opera, from Frank Philipp Schlössmann, is stylish, the set design employs cross-hatching that recalls the work of Edward Gorey. The set is on a quiet turntable that was spun during the first overture. The use of over-sized clocks worked nicely with the main theme of this opera. Olivier Tambosi’s direction was straightforward, only Emilia Marty moved strangely, but given that she is 337, one imagines she may have picked up rather odd habits.

The orchestra sounded lucid and intent under Jiří Bělohlávek. The brass sounded particularly fine, especially the off-stage banda in the beginning. The string and wind soli were all lovely. The male chorus at the end of the opera was haunting.

The cast was incredible. Maya Lahyani sounded great as both as the cleaning woman at the beginning of Act II alongside Austin Kness’ stagehand, and the maid in Act III. Brian Jagde was suitably naive as Janek. Matthew O’Neill was completely convincing as the mad Count Hauk-Šendorf, and even charming. Susannah Biller (Kristina) likewise embodied her role, she was awkward and mousy, and her voice sounded young and flexible.

Thomas Glenn (Vitek) fared well, even singing whilst perched on a ladder, twisting himself toward the audience. Both bass-baritones, Dale Travis and Gerd Grochowski, fit their parts. Travis blustered suitably as Dr. Kolenaty. Grochowski showed his range as an actor, and portrayed various emotions vividly through his voice. Miro Dvorsky was fervid as Gregor, but with the right amount of clumsiness to be plausible. Dvorsky had a just brief moments of being overwhelmed by the orchestra in Act I. Karita Mattila was utterly devastating as Emilia Marty, ruthless yet with unearthly beauty. Her movements were oddly graceful and beastly at the same time.

* Tattling * 
The curtain came down after the singing in Act I, but before the music ended, and this caused people to clap prematurely.
There was some talking in the first half, as Janáček is incomprehensible to some, and the audience attrition after intermission was noticeable. Watch alarms were heard at 9pm.

Posted in , , ,

23 responses to “Věc Makropulos at SF Opera”

  1. Robin Avatar
    Robin

    Spot-on review, dear “OT”. But, you forgot to mention Ms. Mattila’s impromptu “Emilia Marty” moment – in the midst of the first act, scene 2, after Hauk departs….Emila suddenly sits up, facing the rest of the cast in profile….the audience broke into awkward applause…..and “Emilia” turned to face the audience – and gave them a “Stop Applauding, you idiots” look….they did…it was priceless!
    What a fantastic production! Going to see it as often as possible!
    Hugs,
    ♥ Robin ♥

    Like

  2. Doug Avatar
    Doug

    I loved your review OT. I really enjoyed last night, too. It was delightful to see SF Opera mount a new production of a less popular and less immediately accessible opera. While I found the concept a little uninteresting, I was pleased that it was more daring than many recent productions. The cast and orchestra were great. What a compelling evening of theater too — my first experience of this opera.

    Like

  3. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    The part you mention was really perfect, that’s true!
    I’m right there with you, am going to at least 3 more of these.

    Like

  4. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I’m not sure this production was conceptual, it basically just seemed to be moved to the middle of last century, was black and white, and had big clocks. I did enjoy these aesthetics and the high quality of the performance itself. Glad to hear you enjoyed the opera too!

    Like

  5. Sacto OperaFan Avatar
    Sacto OperaFan

    Can’t wait to see it on the 20th. Is it true that it’s a 2 hour show? If so, I can have a after-opera snack at Zuni before driving back to the Valley.
    Thanks in advance.

    Like

  6. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    It is just over 2 hours.

    Like

  7. EBrown Avatar

    I’m awestruck. Last night was perfection: music, acting, production all came together for an unforgettable experience. I am prepared to offer myself as a love slave to Karita Mattila: she is a goddess. I did not think she could surpass her Káťa Kabanová, but she did.

    Like

  8. Doug Avatar
    Doug

    I heard two men behind me talking during intermission (this would be orchestra K 111 & 113 just to report fully here on OT), and one said to the other, “Mattila does nothing for me. She looks like a shoe.” The other guy said, “A shoe.” And then they moved on to another less offensive and equally uninspired topic. So then I found myself considering Ms. Mattila as a shoe during a moment or two of the second half. A consummate artist in nice shoes perhaps, but that is all I could find. Hmmm.

    Like

  9. The Last Chinese Unicorn Avatar

    Well if she were a shoe, she would most certainly be a Roger Vivier or perhaps a Nicholas Kirkwood!

    Like

  10. Joey Avatar
    Joey

    I get excited just by watching the trailer on youtube!
    I can’t wait for more! Maybe I’ll run into you OT 😉

    Like

  11. Doug Avatar
    Doug

    Ha! Totally. If only I had been as quick as you with such a retort to those rude boys, LCU.

    Like

  12. sfmike Avatar

    As a serious opera veteran at this point, you know how unusual it is when all the planets of casting, conductor, production, and magical teamwork align. So it certainly is worth celebrating when it does happen. The production made me proud of the San Francisco Opera for the first time in a while.

    Like

  13. Hank Avatar

    I saw the final dress rehearsal, and will not have a chance to see an actual performance.
    Mattila’s voice is magnificent, large and creamy with effortless delivery. She was a perfect Eva and Elsa in Wagner years ago and she’s developed into a magnificent singer and actress. The other singers were all excellent but they hardly matched her. Of course maybe they were holding back, since it was a rehearsal.
    I did not like the sets, however. I thought they were clunky, and from the balcony (where I happened to be for the final dress), I felt like I was looking at the Houston Astrodome from a seat on the moon, with a football team consisting of four or five players. Especially in act one, the actors were totally dwarfed by the sets. Maybe this was deliberate, but it didn’t work for me.
    The clock I guess had some symbolic significance, but I hope you won’t think I’m nitpicking when I point out that, at least at the final dress, it was keeping real time, and so when one of the characters in the last act asked what time it was, and the answer was ‘A little after seven’, and it was actually about 20 after four… Well, okay, picky picky picky.
    Now as for the ‘whiskey’ that EM was drinking: did anyone else notice that the bottle was a bottle of Southern Comfort? Is this a campy reference to Janice Joplin?
    I’m just wondering.

    Like

  14. Doug Avatar
    Doug

    I didn’t think the concept of “real time” with that looming clock really worked, but I just tried to ignore it. I did enjoy seeing people check their watches during the opera. I suppose they didn’t notice that the director eliminated any such need.

    Like

  15. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I am sort of mad that I can’t go to 2 of the performances because of LA Opera’s Lohengrin and Bryn Terfel at Cal Performances.

    Like

  16. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    The point about the clock is definitely true. I was also at the final dress, but in Box Y, so it didn’t occur to me how small the singers were compared to the set.
    I didn’t notice the bottle of whiskey being Southern Comfort!

    Like

  17. EBrown Avatar

    I thought the sets were wonderful; completely appropriate for the film noir setting. Schlössmann added wit to the dark tale. The endless books and legal briefs, à la Bleak House, supported the exposition in the first act without resorting to a false realism. The silent turning of the set was metaphoric in ways the horrible Butterfly set was not. The costumes were some of the best I’ve seen. Mattila in the white sheath was a vision.

    Like

  18. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I should add something about the costumes, you are right, they are beautiful.

    Like

  19. Roberto Avatar
    Roberto

    Karita Mattila conquered the hearts and souls of the whole house. Her voice is colorful and elastic. She is also very charismatic.
    This whole production is amazing. The sets are breathtaking, the cast very balanced and the Czech conductor and the orchestra are right on the money. It was evident that everybody was having a great time putting together this opera.
    This Janacek opera is also beautiful. One of the crown jewels of the 20th century. Janacek is extremely underrated.
    This is one of the productions that shows why the SF Opera is still in business and what is capable of doing. A pure joy from the beginning to the end.

    Like

  20. AKA Avatar
    AKA

    Wow, did we see the same opera? Maybe the dismal SF Opera season, filled with bad performances and idiotic staging has set the bar so low that reviewers are gushing with praise for an opera that was much less than the sum of its, admittedly, strong parts. The sets, the lighting, the costumes, the orchestra, the conducting and, of course, the singing were top notch. Matilla was outstanding. Yet, where was the passion? The story is barely a one act play in search of a reason to exist. Despite its short performance time, the opera felt interminably slow. The grand theme of being cursed to live a life where one repeatedly loses what one holds dear is lost in the medium of opera. Janacek’s music is beautiful, but there is nothing holding this opera together. Disjointed parts added up to one final thought for us, “Who cares?” In comparison with Cyrano, also with a brilliant but tragically flawed central character, where one is moved to tears at the end, all one can say at the end of Makropulos is good riddance. Kudos to SF Opera for staging something different, but shame on SF Opera for wasting such amazing talent on a truly forgettable piece.

    Like

  21. Doug Avatar
    Doug

    What a fun contrast between Roberto and AKA! For me, this production fell somewhere in between. I didn’t think the production was especially wonderful or interesting though it was well-executed and easy on the eyes. I found the story very interesting and I love how it was like a play as opera in that there were no arias or duets to “interrupt” the action. That said, I, too, found myself void of much emotional experience around the characters or the opera as whole. Maybe its an existential opera before its time. My second viewing (last night) was really good. It was fun to see it from the a different perspective in the house. Not paying as much attention to the supertitles helped me enjoy the music and orchestra even more, too. Janacek is a wonder!

    Like

Leave a comment