Merola 2011 * Notes *
Another Summer of the Merola Opera Program ended with this year's Grand Finale last night at the War Memorial Opera House. Ragnar Conde's staging for the performance was ornate, and the set used was one from Turandot, designed by David Hockney. The costumes were the usual tuxedos and evening gowns, the latter often in a palette of jewel tones ranging from sapphire to pink tourmaline. The dresses were all flattering, which was a nice change from some costume choices at other Merola performances this year. Johannes Debus conducted the San Francisco Opera Orchestra, occasionally the volume of the musicians in the pit overwhelmed the singers. There were also a few synchronization problems. It was nice to hear the overture to Rossini's Semiramide, and the brass was particularly lovely.

"Andiam, fidi, al consiglio…Invida sorte avara" from Ariodante was beautifully sung by Philippe Sly as Il Rè and Daniel Curran as Odoardo. Robert Mollicone's harpsichord playing was pretty here as well. The excerpt from Lucrezia Borgia sung by Renée Rapier (Orsini) and Heath Huberg (Gennaro) that followed was more awkward. Maybe part of the problem was the fussy stage direction, which involved nervous packing and fringed scarves. The first half of the performance did end on a high point, with Jonathan Michie singing "Batter my heart" from Dr. Atomic. Michie was completely convincing, his diction clear, and his voice has warmth and heft.

Ragnar Conde's humor worked well for the staging of "Ich gehe doch rate ich dir" from Entführung, Suzanne Rigden was spunky as Blonde and Peixin Chen a loveable buffoon as Osmin. Another highlight of the evening was "Das war sehr gut Mandryka" from Arabella, with Marina Boudart Harris (Arabella) and John Maynard (Mandryka). Boudart Harris sang imposingly, and without strain. Maynard gamely supported her with his pleasant sound. The last piece of the evening, "O che muso" from L'Italiana in Algeri, was very funny. Everyone eventually came out on stage, including the apprentice coaches, who all seemed to be singing in the chorus. The staging included much choreography, and many parasols were opened and closed. At times it seemed like chaos, but considering the text, it was not inappropriate. Philippe Sly was hilarious as Mustafà, as was Cooper Nolan as Lindoro. Suzanne Rigden managed to be a mousy Elvira, never upstaging Renée Rapier's sassy Isabella. Rapier's full, round sound was marvelous, her timbre is even throughout the ranges of her voice.

* Tattling *
Some light talking was heard when no one was singing on stage. The person in Row O Seat 105 chose to unwrap something during most of "Bel raggio lusinghier" from Semiramide.

Posted in ,

6 responses to “Merola Grand Finale 2011”

  1. Jumping Clapping Man Avatar

    Peixin Chen and Sly were the stars of the night. Chen’s voice was overwhelming, and his comedic timing (in the Mozart) was very effective. Sly is a quintessential “Barihunk”, with acting chops and glorious tone. What a talent!
    I also enjoyed Rigden and Boudart in particular very much. It was disconcerting to hear that many of the women were having fundamental technique problems at this young age. Were they just tired from the grueling program?
    Sadly, overall it was the weakest calibre I’ve seen in the 18 years I’ve been going, and I found the directing heavy-handed and distracting. Personally, I preferred simpler approaches in the past that had a clean, black curtain with no props and minimal staging.
    And, YES, I was in Row S, RIGHT near the notorious wrapper lady. Ugh!

    Like

  2. Lilacrobin Avatar
    Lilacrobin

    Hi dear “OT”,
    I was there too…and thoroughly enjoyed it…though I felt it was a night for the Gentlemen to shine…
    Jonathan Michie….there is a STAR in the making.
    I saw him as the Barber a few weeks ago and was he was fantastic! Now, to see him do something completely different – and do also with passion, bot in singing and acting…I am so impressed.
    Peixin Chen, Philippe Sly were also very good.
    My favourite lady….no contest – Marina Boudart Harris….she brought tears to my eyes….. the only time I was so moved that evening. I did enjoy Xi Wang’s Lucia…an Suzanne Ridgen’s Elvira and Blonde…..
    I am relieved to report that from Row A…everyone was attuned and attentive and no coughing or crackling or crunching occured!
    Hugs,
    ♥ Robin ♥

    Like

  3. support Avatar
    support

    My fave was Renée Rapier. The pitch and tone of her voice always sends chills down my spine !!

    Like

  4. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    It is interesting that this year the lower voices were stronger than many of the higher voices.

    Like

  5. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Glad to hear that you were able to hear the performance without any distractions.
    I was most surprised by Marina Boudart Harris, because she did not stand out for me in any of the other performances over the course of the program. She sang the Strauss with great maturity.

    Like

  6. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    She is also so sweet. Looking forward to hearing her in Los Angeles.

    Like

Leave a comment