15. October 2011: Opening
Opera Tattler Review

18. October 2011: From the Orchestra
* Had a brief discussion about the cuts to the opera with Maestro Luisotti before the performance. When asked why the epilogue was cut, he simply answered that it was thus in the Vienna version. He also explained how the continuo was divided between his fortepiano playing and Bryndon Hassman's harpsichord.
* The overture was much more together, as was pretty much all the playing, except for the end of Act I.
* Shawn Mathey was more confident as Don Ottavio. He can always be heard, but his performance was not particularly nuanced. Some of the voiceless alveolar stops either had aspiration or were subsituted with alveolar flaps.
* Ellie Dehn unraveled during her first aria, "Or sai chi l'onore." She seems terrified of making mistake.
* Vocally, Kate Lindsey (Zerlina) is quite contained.
* Serena Farnocchia's breath control is lacking, but for Elvira, it seems fine.
* Marco Vinco's patter as Leporello is nearly perfect.
* There was some talking from certain audience members.

21. October 2011: From the Balcony
* Luisotti's fortepiano playing is charming and comic.
* A latecomer stuck in standing room saw fit to sit next to me for "Dalla su pace." She turned on her cellular phone, whose buttons intoned high pitches to indicate they were being pressed. She clapped for the tenor even though she spent the entire aria either on her phone or reading the program.
* The first cellist played "Batti, batti" beautifully.
* The audience clapped in before the music was over three times.
* Either the mechanism that is used for Don Giovanni's descent or the smoke machine makes a buzzing that is obvious from the back of the balcony.

23. October 2011: From the Balcony
* Everyone sounded more together and less frightened.
* The end of Act I was less chaotic.
* Lucas Meacham's voice is incredibly pretty. There was a point near the end of the Champagne aria where he sounds out of breath.
* Ellie Dehn's intonation was better.
* Serena Farnocchia swallowed fewer of her low notes at the ends of phrases.
* There were a lot of children at this performance. The smaller ones are invariably better behaved than the larger ones. This seems counterintuitive, shouldn't younger children have poorer impulse control?

26. October 2011: From the Orchestra
* Someone sounded squeaky during "Ho capito! Signor, sì."
* The orchestra was ahead of the singers at the beginning of "Là ci darem la mano."
* The two onstage orchestras for the Act I finale stood whilst playing, a detail I had missed before.
* Someone unfastened his or her shoes during the opera. The velcro straps were noisy.

29. October 2011: From the Boxes
* Quite a lot of fun watching the orchestra and Maestro Luisotti.
* The screens in the corners of the box level were not in use.
* From up close, Kate Lindsey's cartwheel during "Giovinette che fate all'amore" and Ryan Kuster's somersault in Act I Scene 19 were even more impressive.
* The French horns were clear in "Ho capito," and only one note in "Non mi dir" was less than perfect.
* The box subscribers were uncharacteristically silent, there was almost no talking in Boxes W, X, or Y. A bottle of carbonated water was opened during "Ah, fuggi il traditor."
* Ellie Dehn had a very good night, less pitchy and generally stronger.

2. November 2011: From the Balcony
* Pleased to note that the person sharing the bench with me in the balcony was also reading the score.
* Someone collapsed at the north doors of the balcony just before "Dalla su pace." It seemed quite serious, as the person was unconscious and the nurse was called to attend to him.

5. November 2011: From the Balcony
* There was an earthquake measuring 3.2 at 2:52pm. The epicenter was in Piedmont.
* Ellie Dehn sounded fragile during "Or sai chi l'onore." She seemed on the verge of cracking on the penultimate D of the aria.
* The flute, clarinet, and bassoon sounded particularly lovely in "Dalla su pace" this afternoon.

10. November 2011: From the Balcony
* The last performance was consistent with the previous few.
* The horns played cleanly.
* Luisotti was occasionally visible in some of the mirrors. One wonders why the director did not really make use of the mirrors, except to change the scenes.

Posted in ,

12 responses to “Don Giovanni Log”

  1. graustark Avatar
    graustark

    I regret missing Kate’s cartwheel, but I do recall her being rather acrobatic in the Santa Fe Hoffmann two summers ago. On the other hand, I did see Kelly Kaduce do two cartwheels recently as Nedda at the Arizona Opera. Since Kelly was also in Santa Fe that summer singing Butterfly, one may surmise that the two of them spent their spare time together perfecting their cartwheels.

    Like

  2. Roberto Avatar
    Roberto

    What a great Mozart conductor Luisotti is! I already could sense his great affinity with Mozart on last year’s Figaro, but the results from this Don Giovanni is something that only the most accomplished conductors are able to obtain. He used only a small set of the orchestra. I believe that in a not so distant past, high profile (or even the non-high profile) conductors preferred the weight of a large orchestra for Mozart. That is not the case anymore. Nowadays, Mozart is more subtle. That doesn’t mean much, I should say. In some of the newest Don Giovanni recordings that I heard, I missed the Vienna Philharmonic in full blast. But when it works…
    Luisotti was VERY restrained. And there is nothing more beautiful when an orchestra sounds inspired when restrained. The winds just needed the right amount of blow to make their point; violins, violas, cellos and brass were listening to each other and with remarkable color; the timpani was very subtle. The balance was incredible. Luisotti used the fast tempos as Don Giovanni is performed nowadays. The key for a great Don Giovanni is not to lose focus and keep the momentum scene after scene. Each scene has its own nuances and when the next starts there is “let’s go again” on the air. Sometimes, when the orchestra doesn’t connect to the opera, the impression is that the orchestra is saying “do we need to go all over again?”
    I was at the first row of the balcony circle and could see how Luisotti was pleased with the result. In the end, he gave a warm hug to each principal, almost missing the cue to take a bow on the stage. I know that Luisotti knows that he did something unbelievable good. I wish that the audience could understand the amount of energy that Luisotti put together for these performances. My impression is that the audience didn’t get the whole dimension of his work. Luisotti’s Mozart is WAY better than his Puccini. By the way, his fortepiano jazzistic improvisations were also outstanding (we had a fortepiano and a harpsichord for these performances).
    As for the singers, all of them were quite young and on the light side of the scale. Once again, we almost don’t have those powerful Verdi and Wagner singers performing Mozart anymore.
    Morris Robinson (The Commendatore) doesn’t have the “low” for this role. His “Ah! tempo piu non v’e!” was not even close to what it should have been. But almost no one signs that as it should…
    Serena Farnocchia (Donna Elvira) was for me the weakest link of the cast. But once again, this is a role almost impossible to sing. Everybody fails. The only one that could really sing Donna Elvira was Kiri Te Kanawa. And even she sometimes was not successful.
    Kate Lindsey (Zerlina) started unimpressive, but “La ci darem la mano” and her aria on the second act (“Vedrai, carino, se sei buonino”) were quite engaging.
    Ellie Dehn (Donna Anna) was just the opposite. Her duet with Shawn Mathey (Don Ottavio) was a miracle. The orchestra was very restrained and their voices were quite light. The balance was exactly where it supposed to be. It was music for the angels. However, Dehn was tired on the second act and she felt the hardship of her arias. The coloratura was just not there.
    Lucas Meachem (Don Giovanni) is a lyric baritone. He is not a Siepi, Samuel Ramey, Raimondi or Ghiaurov. We all know that. He put a lot of thought in the character and he was quite convincing. The last scene, when he goes to hell, didn’t work. But it never does.
    Marco Vinco (Leperello) was also on the light side. He was serviceable.
    As for this new production, with the mirrors that come up and down, trying to give the ambiance. In the beginning I thought the mirrors were annoying. But shortly after, I realized that they were not intrusive at all. This production is very loyal to the concept of the opera. All elements of the opera seria and buffa are there. The singers move a lot on the stage, helping the opera to “flow”. For what I have been seeing on the new productions in Europe and in the Met, this production is WELL above the average. It is quite good actually. It doesn’t deserve to be forgotten. I hope they are able to export that to other companies.
    As a last remark: they ended the opera when it should. No epilogue on this one. Bravo for that!

    Like

  3. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    One can only hope that was the case, it seems a lovely scenario.

    Like

  4. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    As always, I enjoy reading your comments, Roberto. Thank you!

    Like

  5. sfmike Avatar

    @Roberto: Glad you had a good time but frankly the production sucked, the cast was thoroughly substandard, and Luisotti’s “improvisations” at the fortepiano were embarrassing. I felt ashamed as an old San Francisco Opera queen to be at this “Don” performance (the final one, standing next to the Opera Tattler in the top balcony standing room, who I accused of not warning me of the horror of this production, and she said, yes, she did before I flounced out at intermission). The worst part was looking at the program and realizing who I’ve seen sing these roles before over the decades in San Francisco in this greatest of operas, in comparison with this current dreck of a production with its sad cast.
    In just about every case, the student Merola production from about three years ago at the Cowell Theatre had better singers than this one. Rena Harms, for instance, actually nailed the role of Dona Elvira, The mirrors in this production were stupid, distracting, and didn’t even bother establishing place, whether one was inside or outside. And did I mention Luisotti’s fortepiano? Ugh. The orchestra, meanwhile, sounded wonderful so he was doing something right.
    Start over, please.

    Like

  6. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    That Merola cast was exceptionally good! Too bad the orchestra was so uneven for that performance. Remember the mandolin in that? I wish I didn’t, actually.
    I like Luisotti’s animated playing, but I can understand how it isn’t for everyone.

    Like

  7. Lilacrobin Avatar
    Lilacrobin

    Loved this final Don…. although I, too, disliked those mirrors…. it was fun to catch a glimpse of Maestro Nikki flailing away like a madman…was it me, or was the tempi even quicker? (Perhaps he had a few too many Red Bulls!) I thought his Fortepiano added to the youthful energy on stage! And…in the Canteen, we were treated to see Lucas (in costume) playing ping-pong and stealing some of our food! What a Don!!
    Hugs,
    ♥ Robin ♥

    Like

  8. Roberto Avatar
    Roberto

    sfmike,
    Some people like vanilla and some people chocolate.
    My only comment to what you wrote is that it is not fair to compare the voice projection required for a singer in the Cowell Theater and a major opera house like the War Memorial.

    Like

  9. sfmike Avatar

    Dear Roberto: Of course you’re completely correct that it’s not fair to compare the voice projection required for the Cowell and the War Memorial. So let me put it another way. This was the worst San Francisco Opera “Don Giovanni” cast that I’ve heard since the 1991 production with Gino Quilico as D.G. where I was a servant supernumerary who was embarrassed to be a part of the production. The only real highlight 20 years ago was a young Frank Lopardo as Don Ottavio.
    2011’s dreary cast wasn’t that bad (you really had to hear 1991’s Kallen Esperian trying to sing Donna Elvira to know real musical pain), but it was close. This year’s dreary new production, with its paucity of any design sense or ideas, didn’t help out either. I was happily surprised by Lucas Meacham because the last time I heard him at the San Francisco Symphony he wasn’t sounding so good, but again the director sabotaged him completely by making him do the whole frigging performance in a pair of sunglasses. Meacham might be good in the role with a decent director, but you couldn’t really tell in this dumb show.
    And this isn’t a vanilla and chocolate situation, by the way. I’ve heard Cesare Siepe, Samuel Ramey, and William Shimmell sing the Don, Carol Vaness and Elza van den Heever sing Donna Anna, Anna Netrebko sing Zerlina, and Walter Berry sing Leporello at the War Memorial over the years, among many other great artists taking on this opera. It’s a matter of having some standards. This production and cast was mediocre crap.

    Like

  10. Roberto Avatar
    Roberto

    sfmike,
    In my review I didn’t praise the singers. I really didn’t have much expectation on this cast so I wasn’t that disappointed. What made this Don Giovanni a wonderful night was the conducting, which you also didn’t like. I liked it a lot

    Like

  11. Sacto OperaFan Avatar
    Sacto OperaFan

    Hi OT and Fellow Opera Lovers,
    I was at the Nov 5th performance. It wasn’t as bad as I thought it would be, but it seems I went on a rather “good” day. The faults of the production have been discussed in many of the above posts and I have to concur. I’m not sure why SFO replaced their old DG with this one. The other one wasn’t that old and served it purpose.
    I do wish management would cast these “AAA” operas better. I was lucky to have seen some great Mozart singers who have moved on. Now we have this. Is it me or am I the only one who liked the Don Ottavio? I thought he had a very nice clean voice – perfect for Ottavio. Ellie Dehn has a much larger voice than I remember and thought Donna Anna suited her better than the Countess (seen last year). The Zerlina and Masetto were picture perfect. I was less than satisfied with the other singers; I don’t get what all the ballyhoo is about Meecham….he has a lyric baritone voice, I don’t think Giovanni is a great role for him.
    Anyway….happy returns. I’ll be at Turandot next Friday. Thus far my favorite opera of the season has been Xerxes, which is a very happy surprise.
    Your Admirer from the Valley
    SOF

    Like

  12. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I didn’t like the last Don Giovanni production either. There were some rumors about a particular director staging all 3 Da Ponte operas. Perhaps that fell through and that’s how we got this new production anyway, since we have a rather old Carmen production and the old Hockney production for Turandot.
    Yes, it felt a little like it was the second cast. Don Ottavio wasn’t bad, he has a robust voice. By the end of the run he seemed much more comfortable with the role.
    Agree with you on Xerxes! Thanks for the comments!

    Like

Leave a comment