Tosca-sfopera-moore-2012* Notes *
 
Last night's opening of Tosca at San Francisco Opera was rather more exciting than expected, given that the 1997 production has been revived three times before. As Tosca, Angela Gheorghiu sang Act I a bit quietly, and was often not with the orchestra. Before Act II, General Director David Gockley announced that Gheorghiu had a bout of intestinal distress and nausea at intermission and was going to the hospital. The cover, Melody Moore (pictured above in Act II, photograph by Kristen Loken), was getting into costume, and Gockley begged our indulgence. All things considered, Moore did an excellent job. Her voice sounds icier in this role than others, which is not inappropriate. Her lower register has a lovely vibrancy, in stark contrast to Gheorghiu.

As for the rest of the cast, Massimo Giordano (Cavaradossi) has warm plaintiveness, but did not always sound secure. His portrayal did not have much nuance, but he certainly did project well. Roberto Frontali sang a threatening Scarpia with grit and power. Christian van Horn sounded robust as Angelotti and Dale Travis delivered a comic Sacristan. Joel Sorensen was completely committed to his role of Spoletta, and the spill he took trying to catch up with Moore at the end looked very realistic.

Maestro Luisotti had the orchestra sounding strong, and there was never a lax moment. The clarinet solo that introduces "E lucevan le stelle" was particularly beautiful. The strings also sounded lovely.

* Tattling * 
Cellular phone alarm went off twice during Act I, once toward the end of the duet between Tosca and Cavaradossi and once near the end of the act. A latecomer brusquely yelled "excuse me" into my ear and pushed herself between me and another standee, right at the end of Act I, just before the alarm went off. Her arm was touching mine, so I gently rested against her. I figured she wanted so very much to be near someone else, I might as well oblige her.

According to a statement issued by San Francisco Opera today, Gheorghiu was feeling ill during Act I. Tests at the hospital revealed that she was severely dehydrated. Gheorghiu is now resting up and feeling better. She expects to perform on Sunday, November 18, as scheduled.

Posted in , , , ,

12 responses to “Melody Moore as Tosca at SF Opera”

  1. Joggerboy Avatar
    Joggerboy

    I hope she’s better before the 21st (when I’m seeing it). I had a vague premonition that Gheorghiu’s appearance would not go smoothly. At least she didn’t cancel this time!

    Like

  2. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I’m going to have to catch another performance to hear Gheorghiu too, so sure hope she returns to health soon!

    Like

  3. Laurie Avatar
    Laurie

    Both Gheorghiu and Giordano seemed to be off the orchestra’s tempo in Act I. When the announcement was made during intermission I assumed her illness was the cause, but Giordano continued to be off in the 2nd and 3rd acts. Moore seemed to sync quite well with the orchestra when on her own, but Giordano seemed to be determined on a particular delivery regardless of what the orchestra was doing. The only drawback for me about her performance was that when delivering her high notes, regardless of the emotion of the moment, she always had a pained expression on her face. That said, Moore did a great job I thought, and I would gladly hear her again.

    Like

  4. cedric Avatar
    cedric

    Luisotti was trying so hard to stay with Gheorghiu in Act I, he looked quite tense and strained. He was liberated -and overwhelming!- in Act II.

    Like

  5. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Singers and the orchestra are often off in the first performance, I’ve noticed. I’m sure it will get better as the run progresses.

    Like

  6. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I can believe that. The overwhelming sound was less apparent up in the balcony.

    Like

  7. anjw12 Avatar
    anjw12

    Clarinetist is Jose Gonzalez Granero!

    Like

  8. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I’ve heard lovely things about him from various maestri.

    Like

  9. Shaun Avatar
    Shaun

    you should have seen his expressions via the monitors back stage, weee!

    Like

  10. Joggerboy Avatar
    Joggerboy

    I just came back from the Tosca today and I thought that Gheorghiu was gorgeous! She was a little behind the orchestra in Act I but recovered quite nicely by Act II. I find her lower register especially lovely. The Scarpia was also good. Giordano was also fine, although I’ve liked him better in Gianni Schicchi. I was wondering why Scarpia took a solo bow at the end of Act II and never showed up at the end of Act III with the cast bows. Nevertheless, it was a wonderful performance that I’m glad I saw.

    Like

  11. Chris Avatar
    Chris

    Why are there 30 reviews telling us about the opening night and what happened then, and none reviewing Angela G. after 2 performances she sang?

    Like

  12. Chris Avatar
    Chris

    Except yours Joggerboy.Thanks for your review.

    Like

Leave a comment