Sfopera-mary-magdelene-2013* Notes * 
The world premiere performance of Mark Adamo's The Gospel of Mary Magdalene (Nathan Gunn as Yeshua and Sasha Cooke as Mary Magdalene in Act I pictured left, photograph by Cory Weaver) was held yesterday at San Francisco Opera. The overture had a interesting convoluted quality to it, and in general the orchestra, conducted by Michael Christie, shimmered. The music had labyrinthine moments, but was often straightforward and tuneful. Adamo wrote his own libretto, which seemed quite earnest but had wry glimmers of humor. The best of these may have been when the chorus sang "Ibid." when citing a reference for the second time in Act I.

This opera showcases the beautiful voice of mezzo-soprano Sasha Cooke in the title role. Her clean, well-supported sound has an ethereal sublimity. Nathan Gunn (Yeshua) was a bit wobbly in comparison, but his acting was fine. As Miriam, Maria Kanyova was pointed and piercing, but this did not seem inappropriate for the role. William Burden (Peter) sounded as sweet and lovely as ever. His performance of a particular bridal song at the end of Act I is moving, as was his singing with Cooke in Act II.

The rest of the cast included many young singers in the smaller roles. Current Adler Fellow A.J. Glueckert sang one aria as Levi quite nicely. The chorus sounded solid.

* Tattling * 
Someone who probably has a mental-illness was in Orchestra Standing Room. He talked to himself, fidgeted, repeatedly scratched himself, velcroed and unvelcroed his man-purse for no apparent reason, and managed to scare off four people sharing the railing with him, including me.

Posted in ,

11 responses to “The Gospel of Mary Magdalene World Premiere”

  1. EBrown Avatar

    This was absolutely the worst three hours of opera I have ever experienced. Suddenly, productions I disliked became models of beauty and intelligence. This production made me long for Santa Fe’s Tales of Hoffmann or SFOpera’s recent Madama Butterfly. This summer’s Cosi has been elevated in my mind to sparkling and delightful.
    Adamo has given us a turgid, boring piece which could not be saved by Sasha Cooke’s beautiful voice. Adams seems to have channeled Sondheim, but not in a good way. Echoes of Carousel and Camelot drifted through the score. Voice and orchestra seem to look for each other but never quite meet in a coherent whole. Let me take that back, like the archeological dig setting they vanished into a black hole with the occasional spark in the trash can. Moreover the libretto was embarrassingly bad: repetition does not lend weight if the idea is banal.

    Like

  2. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Thanks for your thoughts.
    The pacing felt slow to me too. I felt embarrassed for Sasha Cooke when sang about being embarrassed, so definitely understand your comments on the libretto.

    Like

  3. EBrown Avatar

    Apologies for all the typos. My iPhone auto-correct is implacable. And I’m EBrown not Enron, in case you wondered. Here are the corrections: Carousel not carosel; seem not seed. Yikes!

    Like

  4. Sibyl Avatar
    Sibyl

    Not sure where to post this, but hearty, huge congratulations on your nuptials!

    Like

  5. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Corrections made. Thank you.

    Like

  6. jsutton Avatar
    jsutton

    I’m sorry to say that I thought this opera soporific and sophomoric. It attempted to be original and controversial, but was neither. Neither the music nor the libretto or even the stage set gained my interest. Sorry.

    Like

  7. Jennifer Avatar
    Jennifer

    My husband and I went on Friday night July 5. I can’t say I was disappointed as I generally don’t like modern operas but I was surprised at what struck me as an amateurish libretto, silly plot points (Jesus has a bachelor party during which the guys extol the charms of MMs bustline?!) and needlessly slow pacing. While much of the singing was lovely it seemed overpowered at times by the orchestra. Likewise, the acting was generally good; Sasha Cooke luminous as MM and William Burden an impassioned and articulate adcicated fir keeping the apostles guys only – MM was kind of like Yoko breaking up the Beatles. Unfortunately these were not enough to save an otherwise flawed opera.
    I am listening to my Manon recording with Henry Legay and Victoria de Los Angeles, trying to forget it ever happened.

    Like

  8. Jennifer Avatar
    Jennifer

    I meant to say advocate for. iPhone error.

    Like

  9. Shane Avatar
    Shane

    I have really enjoyed a few of the modern operas I’ve seen – Nixon in China at SF last year and Anna Karenina at S.J. opera a few years ago. So, I was looking forward to this opera but was greatly disappointed. It was like the libretto was written by a blasphemous Dr. Seuss. I got so bored that I started guessing what the rhyme would be in the next line. I didn’t think much of the music either and as Jennifer said, the orchestra played much too loudly at times. I’m all for S.F. commissioning modern operas but this one was a failure.

    Like

  10. Anthony Alfidi Avatar
    Anthony Alfidi

    This performance of “Mary” was truly awful.

    Like

Leave a comment