Marietta-emily-magee * Notes *
Nearly 88 years after the world premiere, Die Tote Stadt finally opened in San Francisco yesterday evening. The work is certainly a very pretty synthesis of Wagner, Strauss, and Puccini. It is nostalgic, but also prefigures Korngold's work in film scores. The music sounded effortless under the direction of Donald Runnicles, the orchestra did not overwhelm the singers and the tempi were rigorous. The chorus sounded perfectly lovely as well.

All of the smaller singing roles were filled by Adler Fellows, some familiar to the War Memorial stage, such as tenor Andrew Bidlack, soprano Ji Young Yang, and mezzo-soprano Katharine Tier. The other two, mezzo-soprano Daniela Mack and tenor Alek Shrader, had their main stage debuts. They all did well, sounding and looking the parts. Tier was particularly fine as Brigitta, the maid, her diction was clear and her voice is quite promising.

Former Adler Lucas Meachem was convincing as both Frank and Fritz, his acting strong and his volume good. He sang "Mein Sehnen, mein Wähnen" splendidly and without strain. Tenor Torsten Kerl was palatable enough as Paul, there were times when his voice did not quite cut through the orchestra, though he was always audible. On the other hand, Emily Magee's voice soared over the orchestra, she gave a vocally exquisite performance as Marie/Marietta. For the most part her acting was persuasive, though she does not quite have a dancer's self-possession as far as movement is concerned. However, overall the music was gorgeous and everything seemed to come together beautifully.

As I was unable to see much of the production in the balcony, I have little to say about it. From what I could see, it appeared sleek and tasteful. Clearly the set was meant for a different space, and it was annoying when singers' heads could not be seen. The shrine to Mariette was not in evidence as there was almost no furniture, only scattered and badly cropped reproductions of a portrait by John Singer Sargent. The painting of Miss Elsie Palmer looks rather grotesque when blown up to the dimensions necessary for the stage, but was used effectively in the various nightmare sequences. I very much enjoyed the little houses that were moved around upstage, apparently if such stagecraft is used in a dream, it is not considered Eurotrash.

* Tattling * 
There were many empty seats in the balcony, giving me nothing to tattle about as far as audience behavior. However, I did notice, much to my chagrin, that my name appears in the program.

There was a fair amount of banging and crashing as the set was changed, though the aforementioned houses were silent. Emily Magee lost her wig in Act I as she took off her hat, but remained calm, simply smoothing it back onto her head with aplomb.

Posted in , , , ,

22 responses to “Die Tote Stadt at SF Opera”

  1. Niki Avatar
    Niki

    Oh my, now I definitely want to see this opera! Why are you mentioned??

    Like

  2. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    It is certainly the best production thus far.

    Like

  3. Dodaro Avatar
    Dodaro

    Yes please stop playing coy. Why are you mentioned?

    Like

  4. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Such accusations. Shouldn’t you be more interested in the opera itself?

    Like

  5. cedichou Avatar

    But why are you mentioned then?

    Like

  6. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Good gracious. Don’t you all have something better to do than to torment me?

    Like

  7. Sibyl Avatar
    Sibyl

    No, I for one have absolutely nothing better to do. Why the mention?

    Like

  8. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I seem to have painted myself into a corner!

    Like

  9. sfmike Avatar

    I know, but I’m not telling. Let’s just say it has something to do with the initials M.S. (and no, that doesn’t stand for Michael Strickland).

    Like

  10. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Nicely played. Such silliness.

    Like

  11. Henry Holland Avatar
    Henry Holland

    OT, do you remember what row you were in? I bought a ticket today in Row J, so I imagine I won’t see much of the set either.

    Like

  12. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I was all the way in the back, in standing room, so just behind Row L. You’ll see more of the set than I did, but probably not much more.

    Like

  13. Not For Fun Only Avatar

    The Chronicle gave a more skeptical review today. I am still very much looking forward to seeing this on Friday. I was a bit concerned to read in the comments to your previous post that the 1st & 2nd acts have been combined. That makes it a real butt-buster of a 1st half, the kind of thing that gives German opera a bad reputation. 2 intermissions is more humane. This also means that they might have cut some pretty wild orchestral music, most likely from the end of the 1st act. Why do they do this? Is it a cost-cutting thing to keep the total length of the evening under 3 hours?

    Like

  14. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I read the Chronicle review too, and I’m curious to see the opera on the orchestra level. I’ll be there on Friday, do say hello.
    The first two acts also have the two famous pieces, so I didn’t find it particularly long. It must have been hard for the singers though.
    It is not cost-cutting as much as just wanting to keep the length of the evening short, that’s one of the things Gockley has been adamant about.

    Like

  15. Henry holland Avatar
    Henry holland

    Not For Fun Only, doing the first two acts together cuts out some music in the first act, but the bad part is it cuts out most of the incredible prelude to Act II. I think it’s a dumb idea to do it that way, it’s really tough on the tenor.
    And if Gockley is so concerned about running time, why do 3 of the 5 evening performances start at 8:00 pm? Why not do them all at 7:30, do it in 3 Acts and there, people leave at the same time. I suspect he does it to cut costs on all the bar/restaurant staff.

    Like

  16. Not For Fun Only Avatar

    I shouldn’t pass judgment until after I’ve seen the performance, but I’m afraid I don’t approve of losing the prelude to Act II. The orchestral bits are some of the best parts of the opera, & this prelude is important for establishing Paul’s demented state of mind.
    Earlier curtain times would be nice, but they wouldn’t shorten the over-all running time, which Tattler indicates is the issue here. I don’t know whether or not the opera runs the catering, but I doubt it runs at a loss ($10 cocktails?!), & it seems to me that more intermissions would mean more revenue.

    Like

  17. M. C- Avatar

    finally made it here, and just Found you

    Like

  18. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I thought I spotted you in orchestra standing room!

    Like

  19. JJimbo Avatar
    JJimbo

    Why is the cast for Porgy and Bess such a big secret? Shouldn’t we know who’s going to be in it by now? Or has something passed me?

    Like

  20. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    From what I understand, it is not a secret, David Gockley is just having difficulty casting Bess in particular.

    Like

  21. Erik Bruchez Avatar

    Am I reading right that they cut the prelude to act II? That’s just criminal! This is one of the most magnificent pieces of music.
    -Erik

    Like

  22. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Yes, it is quite sad.

    Like

Leave a reply to JJimbo Cancel reply