Vargas-mula * Notes * 
The new production of L'elisir d'amore at San Francisco Opera is quite winning. Adapted from a co-production with Opera Colorado, Boston Lyric Opera, Pittsburgh Opera, Michigan Opera Theatre and Fort Worth Opera, here
the setting was moved to a small town in the Napa Valley during World War I. James Robinson's direction was strong, and all of the acting was convincing and even funny. The set, from Allen Moyer, is simple without being stark, and has no large moving parts. Perhaps a change of scenery between acts would have been nice, but nonetheless, the gazebo used is versitile enough for all the scenes. Martin Pakledinaz used a pastel palette for the costumes, for the most part they were lovely, though the print of Adina's second costume did not read well from afar. Paul Palazzo's lighting was unobstrusive, there might have been one mishap as far as the lights, just as Giannetta and the female chorus come onstage for Act II Scene 4, the transition from a full lights to something more dim was not smooth.

Bruno Campanella took the overture a bit sluggishly, and though orchestra sounded in tune and together with each other, they were somewhat slow. The chorus did a splendid job, as usual. As for the soloists, they fit their roles well. Ji Young Yang (Giannetta) sang effortlessly, and was especially good in Act II. Alessandro Corbelli was a hilarious Dulcamara, his parlando is crisp, though he was a bit faster than the orchestra a few times. Giorgio Caoduro was likewise very good at the physical humor required for this opera, his Belcore was suitably full of himself. Caoduro's voice is pleasant and somewhat husky. Inva Mula's debut was impressive, her voice has good volume and can be quite beautiful. She does have moments of shrillness, at times her control is not completely perfect. Her Adina played off of Ramón Vargas' Nemorino very well, both moved well. Vargas sounded absolutely lovely, his "Una furtiva lagrima" was gorgeous.

* Tattling * 
The audience was somewhat sparse and there were very few late-comers. Some whispering was noted in Act I, but the beginning of Act II was worse, at least for me, as a rather uncouth couple sat near where I was standing in Row ZZ. Not only did they talk during the music, the female half of the couple opened her phone and read a text message. At least they were silent when hushed.

Posted in , , ,

15 responses to “Opening of L’elisir d’amore”

  1. cedichou Avatar

    It was cute. Only the arrival of the war at the end was superfluous/ridiculous. Did not see you in the back, though.

    Like

  2. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Yes, it was adorable. The war bit at the end was heavy-handed, as if to say “Hey, this has to do with you!” Unnecessary, given how appealing the rest of the production was. I was there in the back, but must have been too wily to be seen.

    Like

  3. cheshire cat Avatar
    cheshire cat

    Thanks so much for the report. I wish I could be in SF. Sr. Vargas’ Nemorino is simply the best. So sad to hear that the audience was sparse. Sr. Vargas deserves better. Mr. Gockley has the best taste in terms of choosing singers. Do you know if SF opera is going to broadcast this in the movie theatre or on the internet / radio? Thanks in advance for any info.

    Like

  4. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    The crowds will come in after the reviews come out, I’m sure. They are recording the performances, but as far as I know the broadcast schedule is not yet determined. It is quite likely that the performance will be aired on the radio, and I wouldn’t be surprised if this is picked as one of the cinemacasts for next year.

    Like

  5. cheshire cat Avatar
    cheshire cat

    I’ve no doubt the reviews will be great. Anyone who loves opera and has ears would have known about Sr. Vargas by now. He’s been singing and bringing joy to audiences all over the world for over 20 years. His stellar reputation alone should bring the crowds to the opera house. I don’t even know how to start to describe his artistry. This is such a delightful and fun opera to watch with a first-class cast and very lovely staging. We need some fun and laughter, not to mention great singing in such depressing times. I sure hope it will be in the cinemacasts in the spring. Thanks for the update.

    Like

  6. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    It looks like you are right, the intial reviews look very good indeed.

    Like

  7. EBrown Avatar

    Vargas was simply sublime. His voice has a warmth usually absent from a tenor. I’m ready to become his groupie.
    I found the production charming although I kept on thinking about the movie “East of Eden” for some reason.
    As for the audience, I was surprised so many left at the 2d intermission. Why? I have one plea: don’t use fragrance when going to a performance of any kind. Some of us have allergic reactions to scents that would not bother us in less close quarters.

    Like

  8. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Vargas was amazing.
    I’ll second you on that fragrance plea, part of the reason I prefer standing room is that I can get away from all the perfume.

    Like

  9. Upstairs Tenor Avatar
    Upstairs Tenor

    As I’m one of the supers holding up the infamous newspaper, I should keep my mouth shut about my personal feelings about it, but I will say this: the rational, as it was explained to us (very briefly) is to bring the opera back to reality.

    Like

  10. Sibyl Avatar
    Sibyl

    I was really squirming over not being able to see this show ($$), as I adore Vargas and really wanted to see Corbelli live after seeing him in the MET Fille, then even more squirming after your review. So I was thrilled when the SFO did an online half-price sale on Thursday. YAY! I can go now! Thanks for a great blog, btw.

    Like

  11. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Dear Upstairs Tenor: Thanks for letting us know!
    Dear Sibyl: Thanks so much! I’m so glad you will be able to see a performance of this.

    Like

  12. John Crowe Avatar
    John Crowe

    You got it just right; the overture was torture (one could wish for a return of Patrick Summers with his heavy hand), but the rest of the performance was splendid. Vargas is always a treat, of course, and in this comic role he reveals a talent I hadn't seen before. John Belushi would have approved.

    Like

  13. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Vargas was very funny!

    Like

  14. stephen Avatar

    I saw this last week. Vargas was fabulous, beautiful singing, very funny acting. The whole thing was very good except for the totally unnecessary sour note at the end about the war. It is a bit disturbing that ticket sales are apparently so low that SFO is having to have half-price sales online. If a well-known opera like Elisir with one of the greatest stars in opera today, Vargas, is struggling with ticket sales it does not bode well. I have seen every opera SFO has done this year and enjoyed them all tremendously.
    Thank you for this entertaining blog which I have just discovered.

    Like

  15. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Dear Stephen: I'm worried about the ticket sales as well, it's a shame, given how perfectly lovely this production is. Thank you for reading!

    Like

Leave a reply to The Opera Tattler Cancel reply