11. October 2008: Final Dress Rehearsal
Review from Dodaro

15. October 2008: Opening
Opera Tattler Review

18. October 2008: From the Orchestra
*
An announcement was made that Alice Coote was ill, but was graciously singing despite this. She started off poorly, but did sound lovely for the most part, at least in Acts II and III.
* There were many watch alarms, including one with at least 8 beeps in a row. One would think someone would tell the owner of the watch to turn it off, but no, it sounded at both 9pm and 10pm. Unfortunately, 9pm was during Ilia's "Se il padre perdei." Kurt Streit also coughed once as Genia Kühmeier sang this aria.
*
People whispered and talked quite a bit.
* Kurt Streit did not have as much trouble with his costume, it did not seem to get caught on the set this time. His singing is very compelling.
* Iano Tamar had more trouble with her "Tutte nel cor vi sento" than in the opening performance. She was more audible this time, but her intonation suffered. However, the other arias were better, especially "Idol mio."
*  I was very kindly given a third row seat in the premium orchestra section after the first intermission. It is incredible what one can see from that close up.

21. October 2008: From the Balcony
*
As I waited for standing room to open, I heard Genia Kühmeier practicing her first recitative and aria. Then someone was heard playing bagpipe from across the street.
* There are some cuts, but these are mostly of recitative.
*
The performance was consistent with the previous ones, Acts II and III are stronger than Act I.
* The pain in Kurt Streit's "Fuor del mar" is palpable.

24. October 2008: Daniela Mack as Idamante
*
An announcement was made that Alice Coote had hurt her back, and Daniela Mack was singing Idamante. Mack's vibrato is a bit too wide for Mozart. Though her voice is not as breathy, it lacks the warmth and resonance of Coote's.
* Two arias are cut from Act III, Arbace's "Se colà ne' fati è scritto" and Idomeneo's "Torna la pace al core."

* Most of the repeats are not taken.
The matinée audience was characteristically ill-behaved. Late-comers were boggled that they could not get to their seats and were kept in standing room. A particular woman with her child was especially irritating. Her mobile phone rang and she was unable to silence it without making a huge fuss. She also spoke aloud, and huffed when I hushed her. So much the worse for her, as she paid more attention to the recitatives and not the arias.
* There were many beeps, perhaps coming from the machine associated with OperaVision on the north side of the building in balcony standing room. Someone came to look at the machine during the second intermissions, but it still seemed to make noises.

28. October 2008: Daniela Mack from the Orchestra
*
Evidently, they did not want to pay for someone better suited to the role of Idamante as the cover. It is too bad, given that Mack does have a good voice, it is just not shown to best effect here.
* Kurt Streit sounded like he was on the verge of breaking, one felt like his voice would crack at any moment during Acts II and III. This was exciting, but scary.

* There were numerous beeps and some feedback, perhaps from OperaVision, though it was difficult to pin-point.

* The audience was pretty quiet, though someone had a rather loud, rustling jacket in standing room.

31. October 2008: Halloween
* Unfortunately, Alice Coote did not end up returning for the last performance. Daniela Mack still sounded tentative, her first aria was shaky ("Non ho colpa"), though her second one ("l padre adorato") went better. She sounded fine in the quartet in Act III.

* Kurt Streit sounded less on edge than in the penultimate performance. His vibrato could be somewhat wide, but still controlled.

* I hope to hear Genia Kühmeier again soon, her voice is just so lovely.

* Something must have happened during the overture, as there was much giggling at one point.

* There was no noticeable electronic noise, interestingly.

* The audience was fairly good, but there were a couple of latecomers that talked for an incredible length of time and had no regard for the various people giving them dirty looks.

* For Halloween, I dressed as Carmen, and someone had her photo taken with me.

Posted in ,

18 responses to “Idomeneo Log”

  1. sfmike Avatar

    Finally went tonight (Tuesday) and couldn’t make it past the first act. When you’re praying for the next chorus to start because the soloists are all so mediocre, it’s not a good sign. Oh, well.

    Like

  2. Miss Z Avatar
    Miss Z

    Did Alice Coote sing tonight?

    Like

  3. sfmike Avatar

    No, it was Ms. Mack again.

    Like

  4. Miss Z Avatar
    Miss Z

    Thanks for letting me know. I’m flying up from San Diego and am really hoping Alice sings the last performance…

    Like

  5. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    sfmike: The 1st act has been weaker than the other two for pretty much all of the performances. I know you aren’t fond of Mozart, but maybe try Act II on Friday if you have time. The chorus is especially great in the production though, so you certainly have a point.

    Like

  6. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Miss Z: I hear that Coote plans to sing on Friday.

    Like

  7. Miss Z Avatar
    Miss Z

    OT: Thanks for the heads up — I hope you are right.
    By the way, I love Precious Cupcake!

    Like

  8. sfmike Avatar

    Dear OT: Actually, I adore Mozart and all the music in this opera, but the soloists seriously sucked during the first act on Tuesday. Part of the problem is that I’ve pretty much memorized an old recording with Pavarotti, Agnes Baltsa, Lucia Popp and Edita Gruberova. I certainly didn’t expect the cast to be at that level, but was surprised at how lackluster they turned out to be, at least in the first act. Looked for you at the box bar at intermission, but you were nowhere to be seen so I figured it was time to go.

    Like

  9. Extatic Avatar

    Sorry for the intrusion, but I’ve chosen to display your blog I really like in one of those chains Internet spreads like clouds of dust.
    http://lespecheursdeperles.blogspot.com/2008/10/to-tag-or-to-be-tagged.html

    Like

  10. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Dear sfmike: Ach, I’m obviously confused. Was it just that you don’t like Magic Flute? Am I just making this up?
    I’ve only heard the Met DVD a few times, the one with Pavarotti, Flicka, Hildegard Behren, and Ileana Cotrubas. Pavarotti sings much more beautifully than Kurt Streit, but I find Streit’s raw, painful rendering of Idomeneo much more interesting.
    I was at the box bar, but was disguised. 😉

    Like

  11. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Extatic: How fun! Thank you.

    Like

  12. sfmike Avatar

    Dear OT: Love the music to “Magic Flute,” the actual opera not so much. Same goes for “Seraglio” and “Cosi.” Love both the music and drama in “Giovanni,” “Figaro,” “Idomeneo” and “La Clemenza de Tito.” Glad we’ve got THAT cleared up.

    Like

  13. Roberto Nhuch Avatar
    Roberto Nhuch

    I went to the 10/28th performance. There was no way that the production would work. I think that the fundamental flaw was that they took too literally the concept that Idomeneo is an “opera seria”. It is not. You cannot show it as if it is a late Mozart opera. It has some lightness typical of other operas from that period that requires spontaneity and public involvement. This production was too heavy; the acting too stiff; the audience as distant as possible. That was the problem. The singers didn’t help either. If they have showed less restraint, maybe the production would have a chance. Nobody seemed to be inspired and it was a rather cold performance. Genia Kühmeier was the only one that caught my interest. I am not sure if Alice Coote would have saved the night either.

    Like

  14. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Dear sfmike: O yes, me too. Such nuanced views, I will try my best to remember this before I type next time.
    Dear Roberto Nhuch: I felt very engaged by the chorus, Streit, and Kühmeier, but I would have to say it is because of the music rather than the production. Coote seems to be the most beloved singer in this, just judging by the people I’ve read or talked to about the performance.

    Like

  15. cedichou Avatar

    Dear OT: I take (slight) offense with your last comment, Kühmeier was my most beloved singer, heads and shoulder above the rest! If Mack was doing the rest of the run, I’d go back to check that out. Coote did not impress me that much.

    Like

  16. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Dear Ced: My dear, you are in the minority. I loved Kühmeier too. Coote didn’t impress me that much, but even when she had a cold she sang a lot better than Daniela.

    Like

  17. Not For Fun Only Avatar

    I definitely enjoyed Genia Kühmeier’s singing the most in this cast. I’m curious, Tattler, if you noticed if any of the singers did embellishments. Kurt Streit did some fancy coloratura singing in some of his arias, but maybe Mozart had that all written out?

    Like

  18. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Kurt Streit had a cadenza that was not written in the score, near the end of “Fuor del mar.”

    Like

Leave a reply to sfmike Cancel reply