3-decembers   * Notes *
The West Coast premiere of Jake Heggie's Three Decembers was presented by Cal Performances and San Francisco Opera last night. This chamber opera involves just three singers and less than a dozen musicians, including two pianos played by the composer himself and the conductor, Patrick Summers. The work is unchallenging, the arias sound not unlike numbers in a musical. The evening went well, though there were synchronization issues between singers and musicians near the beginning. Interestingly, the orchestra was upstage, behind the singers.

The singing and acting was all quite fine. Soprano Kristin Clayton (Beatrice) had a lovely iciness to her voice, in contrast to baritone Keith Phares (Charlie), whose tones were smooth and warm. Their duet at the end of Act I was lovely. Frederica von Stade embodied her part as the actress and absent mother Madeline. Her voice, though shaky at times, was very effective.

The pacing of this work was good, not utterly glacial and boring as some new operas can be. Gene Scheer's libretto could have been entirely sappy, but somehow managed not to be. The staging, directed by Leonard Foglia, was artful and simple for the most part. The years projected on the scrim to set the various scenes seemed unnecessary.

* Tattling * 
Zellerbach Hall was not at all full, and there were only a few latecomers. There was some talking during the first half, but otherwise the audience was quite silent.

I must have been looking particularly characteristic of the Opera Tattler, for I was recognized and greeted by both the Chronicle's classical music critic and the General Director of San Francisco Opera.

Posted in , , , ,

8 responses to “Three Decembers”

  1. Patrick Avatar

    Hey, no one recognized (or greeted) me, and I just posted a picture of myself!
    I thought you might be there but I didn’t see you — where were you sitting?

    Like

  2. sfmike Avatar

    That’s because you shy away in public like a hunted rabbit, Patrick. Speaking of which, was your reaction to “3 Decembers” closer to Kosman being amusingly bitchy or OT being amusingly polite?

    Like

  3. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    To be fair, I have introduced myself to both the people in question.
    I was in the front of the Tier. Sad to have missed you!

    Like

  4. Patrick Avatar

    Well, I was kind of joking. I’ve never met Kosman and would probably go up to the wrong person. And I doubt Gockley wants to meet me. 😉
    Where is the Tier in Zellerbach? the first balcony? Did the amplification bother you?
    Mike, what a hilariously bizarre description of me! I’m always towards the front and I stand before the show and during intermissions, looking angry and aggressive. I figure I’m there if anyone wants to find me. You make it sound as if I’m ducking under the seats.
    You don’t want to wait three months to find out what I thought of 3 Decembers? I’ll bump it up in the queue. I’ll probably be politely bitchy, or bitchily polite.

    Like

  5. Patrick Avatar

    OK, I just read Kosman’s review (thanks for the link, OT!), and I probably shouldn’t have, since my feelings were probably along the same lines, and he even referenced the Sondheim song I was going to take the entry title from. Ah well, I guess I shall proceed anyway.

    Like

  6. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    The tier is one level up, indeed. The amplification did not bother me, it just seemed like a musical to me, more than anything else.

    Like

  7. Upstairs Tenor Avatar
    Upstairs Tenor

    This was an interesting one….I got a rush seat Friday night and was put in the center orchestra in row D (20 bucks!) so my visceral reaction to the show was a thought process akin to “Oh my God oh my God Flicka is singing ten feet away from me and she’s awesome oh my God!” for two hours, so I enjoyed it very much. I liked the score a lot (I thought it needed more power in the big fight scene in act two, apart from that…ravishing) and I adored all three singers. But on further reflections, I realize that the libretto is weak, if not as weak as Kosman thinks (I didn’t find the kids whiny at all) but there is a lack of dramatic continuity and tension.

    Like

  8. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I enjoyed the performance as well, but not enough to want to hear it again any time soon.

    Like

Leave a reply to The Opera Tattler Cancel reply