MMDG_LAllegroIlPenserosoEdIlModerato * Notes * 
The Mark Morris Dance Group just finished a run of L'Allegro, Il Penseroso ed Il Moderato at Cal Performances. It seemed to be a success, the audience was entertained and amused. The dancing struck me, however, as sloppy. Many of the angles as far as arm and leg positions were not consistent on different dancers, and it did not help that the body types were so disparate. Even the running was not clean, at least one person tripped, though she recovered quickly and did not fall. The choreography itself seemed to prolong the music, and except for the very beginning, when everyone dashed around on stage, it was not surprising. Morris goes for all the cheap laughs, so naturally, simulated canine urination, spanking, and the like.

The Philharmonia Baroque Orchestra lilted under the direction of Jane Glover. The woodwinds had some moments of imprecision, but the strings sounded fine. The chorus sounded beautiful and unsullied, in contrast to the soloists, all of whom had issues. Soprano Christine Brandes gasped and was shrill, though her last air was pretty. Soprano Lisa Saffer had too much vibrato at times, but did sing well for the most part. The tenor, Iain Paton, sounded as if he was running out of air, though his timbre was bright and lovely. James Maddalena's baritone was slightly shaky and thin.

* Tattling * 
It seemed that everyone in attendance was having a grand time. There was quite a lot of talking and giggling, but no electronic noise.

For some reason, the lights were left on during the overture, but were turned off once the singing got underway. It was not possible to follow along with the libretto, but at least this meant less noise, as there was less incentive to leaf through the program.

Posted in , ,

8 responses to “MMDG’s L’Allegro, Il Penseroso ed Il Moderato”

  1. Doug Avatar
    Doug

    Oh OT… thank goodness I’m not alone. I saw it on Saturday night as well and found it really bad. The chorus was lovely, and PBO was good but not as strong as usual. I felt that Jane Glover’s pacing was a bit slow… but I don’t really know enough to say that with confidence. Mark Morris’ choreography was so uninspired and cheap that I was really surprised… even relative to his usual stuff. Maybe I was hoping for the impossible with him. The audience sure loved it. The next evening my husband and I watched Sasha Waltz’ Dido & Aeneas from Berlin on DVD. Now THAT was choreography.

    Like

  2. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I was terribly confused, since I enjoy modern dance, PBO, Haendel, and absurdity. Somehow it didn’t add up for me!

    Like

  3. sfmike Avatar

    Don’t tell anybody, but I felt pretty much the same way the last time they dragged this over to Zellerbach, probably about 10 years ago. I like a lot of Mark Morris and a lot of Handel but found myself excruciatingly bored, and of course the audiences at Zellerbach for events like this are enough to make one want to kill oneself.

    Like

  4. bean Avatar
    bean

    GASP DID YOU SEE BALLET WITHOUT MEE!!!!!!

    Like

  5. Not For Fun Only Avatar

    After reading this report & the comments, I don’t feel so bad about not getting the performance either. I started to tired of it after a while, but since I have very little exposure to dance, I wondered if I was not appreciating it out of simple ignorance. The rest of the audience was having a grand time.

    Like

  6. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I enjoyed both the Gluck and the Purcell works with Mark Morris’ choreography. Though maybe I wouldn’t have liked it as much had I been sitting further away, like on Saturday. Some mistakes are easier to see from a distance.

    Like

  7. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Remember when we went to Dance Theatre of Harlem in Seattle at the Paramount? That was still ballet, even if it was to James Brown. Mark Morris is not ballet.

    Like

  8. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I don’t know that there was that much to get, Morris is very literal, in many ways.

    Like

Leave a reply to Doug Cancel reply