Kate Lindsey (Amelia) and William Burden (Dodge). © Rozarii Lynch photo * Notes *
The world premiere of Daron Aric Hagen‘s Amelia had a promising opening at Seattle Opera last night. The production, directed by Stephen Wadsworth and designed by Thomas Lynch, is both smart and tasteful. Some of the scene changes were rather noisy, and this was particularly unfortunate as it interrupted the music.

Wadsworth’s story came together in the libretto, written by poet Gardner McFall. The text did not display the awkwardness that marks many contemporary operas. The words fit the music, and the deft overlapping of narratives condensed the plot without being confusing or tedious. Layering of the Icarus myth and the life of Amelia Earhart with the main story line worked surprisingly well. There were a few moments that were ungainly, and it might have been better to be shown rather than to be told, given that this was an opera.

The orchestra, conducted by Gerard Schwarz, sounded lively. The brass sounded clear in Act I, but perhaps had more trouble with the second half. The cello sounded brilliant, especially at the beginning of Act I Scene 2. Hagen’s orchestration could be overgrown, and at times it was somewhat difficult to hear certain arias. However, the use of silence was effective and compelling. There was quite a lot of singing as an ensemble, and the voices were handled astutely. The a cappella section at the end was striking.

The singing was all quite lovely. Museop Kim, David Won, and Karen Vuong were convincing in their duel roles as North Vietnamese villagers and American hospital staff. The voices of Nicholas Coppolo (Icarus/Young Boy) and Jordan Bisch (Daedalus/Young Boy’s Father) were evocative and blended nicely together. As the young Amelia, Ashley Emerson was eerily child-like. Her voice was very pretty, flexible, and youthful.

Jane Eaglen fit the role of Amelia’s Aunt Helen perfectly, and produced a full sound without overwhelming the others. Jennifer Zetlan cut a cunning figure as the Flier, the way she sat on the hospital bed with utter aplomb as Amelia is whisked off was strangely delightful. Zetlan’s voice was piercing, a good foil for Eaglen. Nathan Gunn was fine as Paul, the husband of Amelia, as was Luretta Bybee as Amanda, her mother. William Burden (Dodge) sounded warm and sweet, and could be heart-rending. Mezzo-soprano Kate Lindsey impressed in the title role with her clear, bright voice.

* Tattling * 
There was some light talking during the music. A cellular phone rang during Act II as William Burden sang.

This was the first time in many years that I was not in standing room for Seattle Opera, and my press contact for Amelia made sure I was sent to the box office for a seat upgrade. I was right in front of the composer himself on the orchestra level.

Posted in , , , , ,

18 responses to “Amelia at Seattle Opera”

  1. Joncaves Avatar

    Hmm .. I would have sworn that the cellphone rang during the 2nd Act. I also feel that musically this opera requires a second listening … things moved along a such a pace that it was difficult to take the time to focus on the music.

    Like

  2. DanB Avatar
    DanB

    Nice review. No mention of Ashley Emerson as young Emelia?

    Like

  3. odaraia Avatar

    The production quality was flawless: singers especially, everyone seemed very well rehearsed. I liked the car, the starry sky, the Puget Sound late afternoon skyscape and the planes. However, there were many thematic and organizational problems for me as a viewer/listener. The long gaps between scenes- surely not for scene changes?- could have benefitted from some kind of visual narrative continuity, such as film projection and digital composition (such as jet engines). Also, there was formal discontinuity between American sets and Vietnamese, especially as flashbacks. What was the meaning of the visual of scrim walls?
    The music, although very conservative, improved in the second half because the singing became interactive after Ms. Eaglen entered. Inserting Bernstein-esque phrases seemed compatible with the conductor’s ability not to help listeners know where the music was going nor where it had been.
    I’m not going to comment on the libretto nor the plot other than I liked the back and forth layering of time and space. I would have liked the music to support or counterpoint this formal approach. The focus on private matters instead of relating to context was disappointing at best.

    Like

  4. Martin Avatar
    Martin

    I enjoyed the polytonality of some of the sung scenes.The composer’s days with Bernstein has paid off. What was the intended message of the opera? Was it a critique of war or was it a look at human loss coupled with the dream of flight?

    Like

  5. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    My mistake! I was trying to get my review posted as fast as I could.
    I find that for most operas I need to hear them at least twice to have any inkling of what is going on, but you are right, the pacing here did make it perhaps even more difficult to figure out.

    Like

  6. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Thank you! Good point, that is an oversight on my part. Ashley Emerson was eerily child-like and has a very pretty voice.

    Like

  7. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Thanks for your thoughtful response. I did like that though there were so many scrims that they chose not to go the route of projections, which we see such a lot of these days. Compare this to the Wadsworth/Lynch Iphigénie, which is, in my opinion, too busy.
    As for the music, yes, it was quite conservative. I do wonder what it would be like to hear as a recording.
    I did like how the libretto did not hit one over the head with “and the larger message of this opera is x,” as with something like Appomattox. It could have easily been much more cloying, though I understand your point.

    Like

  8. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I think that’s the interesting part about this opera, it seems open to interpretation.

    Like

  9. Don Morgan Avatar
    Don Morgan

    Thank you all for such wonderful feedback and insights. I can hardly wait to experience Amelia myself.
    Don Morgan

    Like

  10. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Thanks for stopping by. Enjoy!

    Like

  11. Eric Avatar
    Eric

    I just saw the performance and enjoyed it immensely. I found the layering and richness of the libretto to be a huge breath of fresh air after what I felt was a rather dull season of Guiseppi “make sure you don’t throw the wrong baby in the fire” Verdi.
    Sincere congratulations to all who made Amelia possible. I’d love to see this one make it into the canon.
    -Eric

    Like

  12. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    That’s wonderful to hear!

    Like

  13. R Ward Avatar
    R Ward

    I have seen this opera three times, now, once at a dress rehearsal and twice at a regular production. Today’s presentaton was the best in all respects but one. I did like Nathan’s Gunn’s vocal delivery better than David McFerrin as Paul, but McFerrin had a terrific stage presence. The singers have become much more comfortable with their characters. Several small changes in lines and stage actions have removed some small irritations, especially those that caused nervous laughter and unease at inappropriate times by the audience.
    Between the dress rehearsal and the opening, Hagan added a few minutes to the entre-act music to fill the delays of scene changes (which have become much less noisy). I have fallen in love with that entre-act music. It is very dense and needs several hearings, but creates more emotional impact every time I hear it. I hope one day to hear an Amelia Suite or some other composition with that music at its core. I found that I could discern several phrases that Hagen uses like leit motifs, not to delineate a specific character, but to signal a specific emotional response.
    Many opera’s have tried to present emotions from a woman’s point of view. I think this opera succeeds more than any other. Several of my female friends agree. I found it striking that the opera equated childbirth with the heroics of mythical and real characters’ feats in both power and accomplishment.

    Like

  14. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Thanks so much for weighing in, I do hope we get more chances to hear this opera.

    Like

  15. Robert Porter Avatar
    Robert Porter

    I too liked the entre-act music and was not bothered by the length of time between scenes. The car, the plane, helicopter? were great effects. Some of us felt the childbirth scene, while wonderful musically, was a bit much! I particularly liked the punch of the Vietnam scene and was sorry there wasn’t more of it.

    Like

  16. Opera Lover from Seattle Avatar
    Opera Lover from Seattle

    Odaria wrote: “I’m not going to comment on the libretto nor the plot other than I liked the back and forth layering of time and space. I would have liked the music to support or counterpoint this formal approach. The focus on private matters instead of relating to context was disappointing at best.”
    I loved your comment with the exception of the words above with which I disagree. First, this was an opera about people’s interior lives, not a political tract. Art is always most potent when dealing with human emotions, not trying to talk politics. Second, I think you missed the point of the musical score entirely: it takes the lead in weaving together the visual and textual images, the characters, and the situations. It, in fact, creates the context in which they could be coherently understood, while amplifying, commenting upon, and deepening, their impact.

    Like

  17. Lilly Avatar
    Lilly

    I saw the opera twice…opening night and closing night. The cell phone definitely rang in Act 2, right before Amelia fainted in Paul’s office.
    I really enjoyed both performances, however I definitely got more out of it the second time. The music was not so foreign to me and the action seemed to flow a little more. The scene changes also didn’t seem to take so long the second time around.
    All of the singers were fantastic and I loved the Vietnamese village scene. Having personally worked with Stephen Wadsworth in a previous Seattle Opera production, I am a big fan. Every move has a purpose and none of the staging seems trivial or wasted.
    This opera was an excellent choice for a Seattle Opera commission. Bravo!

    Like

  18. Pi Avatar
    Pi

    I saw the opera on the last night, 9 other family members attended also and we uniformly enjoyed it.
    I agree with much of what was said here – I also appreciated the use of humor to create a bit of relief in the last act. The tip that it was intentional is that one may need either an insider’s knowledge of hospital scenes and labor and delivery or at least to have been present leading up to and during a delivery to “get” some of the jokes.
    All of the adults in the family were crying at the end (embarassing, but true!) – I particularly appreciated the themes of loss, fear and the uncertainty of life. Felt this opera was an effective means of communicating to the audience on a deep level about these common elements of the human experience.

    Like

Leave a comment