LA Opera's Siegfried, Photo by: Monika Rittershaus/LA Opera * Notes * 
Siegfried was performed yesterday as part of Los Angeles Opera's Ring Festival. James Conlon kept the orchestra sounding fairly restrained, the brass continued to have rough patches, but the singing and playing was more synchronized than in the first two operas. Stacey Tappan shimmered as the Waldvogel, her fluttery voice is suited to the role. Jill Grove sounded rather nice as Erda, earthy but not overly pretty. Eric Halfvarson's Fafner was remarkably sympathetic, especially in his death scene. Graham Clark likewise was fine as Mime, his voice is bright, his acting was clear and strong.

Again, both Richard Paul Fink (Alberich) and Vitalij Kowaljow (Wotan) continued to impress, embodying their roles with vigor. The two leads fared less well, though both were maddening in that sometimes their voices were extraordinarily lovely. Linda Watson could sound harsh as Brünnhilde, but her "Heil dir, Sonne! Heil dir, Licht!" was splendidly beautiful. John Treleaven also could sound brilliant and sweet, but more often he was just getting through this very difficult music, and was still standing at the end, at least.

Achim Freyer's production is consistent in its absurdity. The dragon was especially hilarious, it looked like a tiny puppet on wires, and had plumes of red lights attached to its mouth. One imagines that we are seeing Fafner from Siegfried's fearless point of view here. Siegfried is a clowns around, and his buffoonery is on full display. Though flawed, he somehow did not seem very human, so it was a bit hard to relate to him. Also, the way Fafner's wounding was staged was somewhat confusing if one has not read the libretto, given that the beast we see is so small.

* Tattling * 
The talking was at a minimum for Act I, though a cellular phone rang during the overture. More electronic noise followed in the middle act, a watch alarm rang at least 20 times. There was much speaking from the audience in Act II, and the person next to me in Row H of the orchestra had to implore the woman and girl behind him to be silent. They apologized during the second intermission, and were silent the rest of the opera. Unfortunately this was not the case for the German-speaking couple closer to the middle of Row J, they spoke openly without the slightest bit of embarrassment.

There was a press reception that I had the pleasure of attending. Evidently Quentin Tarantino was also present.

Posted in , , , ,

10 responses to “Siegfried at LA Opera”

  1. CruzSF Avatar
    CruzSF

    Thanks for these reviews. You have me on the edge of my seat, waiting for the next post from this very “controversial” staging. I can’t wait for our own Ring to get started.

    Like

  2. Robin Avatar
    Robin

    Great reporting! Somehow, I am not deeply disappointed that I missed this “Ring”….with all of the chaos onstage – and in the seats – will look forward to our (what should be) glorious “Ring” next year. Meanwhile – our “Walkure” continues to sparkle and shimmer. Nina Stemme is so unbelieveably talented…as are the rest of the cast.
    See you next week! And many thanks again for being our intrepid reporter on the scene!
    ♥ Robin ♥

    Like

  3. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    My pleasure! I am surprised how much I am enjoying this Ring, but of course I am looking forward to the Ring in SF as well.

    Like

  4. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Thank you! While I am very grateful that I was able to make it to this Ring, I am sure it is not meant for everyone. It is great to hear the SF Walküre is coming together. See you soon, and you are most welcome!

    Like

  5. WallhallSB Avatar
    WallhallSB

    Thank you for your post! I really appreciate how you take note of the incredibly stupid person with an annoying cell phone that was ringing away during the overture. At first I though sound was part of the score, but alas, realized this to be a disruption of our embarkation into this Ring world. I was at the press reception as well and was able to talk to Quentin Tarantino, oscar-winning actor Christoph Waltz, the director Achim Freyer, as well as various radio and writing personalities. One conclusion was that the little toy/doll dragon does not work and the death of the dragon/Fafner figure was under-staged. Also, the lighting was quite extraordinary, the more I think about the colors and angles. Siegfried was a complete cartoon figure (again, like a toy) which did not work very well. But, so far, the visual storytelling is pretty amazing. We are looking forward to Gotterdammerung.

    Like

  6. Anthony Fairfax Avatar
    Anthony Fairfax

    Watch alarms on the hour continue on, performance after performance, year after year.
    For more than two years, I have tried to get the SF Opera to update its supertitle reminder (at the start of the performance) about cell phones and electronic devices to add specifically “digital watches.”
    That may be the “a-ha” that the doltish patrons need to turn off their alarms (99% men BTW).
    Here is my suggested language. Perhaps you or your readers have a better suggestion:
    “Please turn off mobile phones, pagers, watch alarms and other audible devices. Violators will be summarily removed and hung from their thumbs until intermission. Thank you.”

    Like

  7. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Siegfried was definitely very cartoon-like, as was the Dragon. For Siegfried, he is already such a clown, I don’t know that I need that pointed out by the production. For the dragon, I was extremely amused, it worked for me, but I can see how it doesn’t for everyone.

    Like

  8. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    It really is a nuisance. I discovered that many people cannot hear the sounds intoned by their own watches, because the pitch is somewhat high. I wonder why the manufacturers of such watches make them default to making noise.

    Like

  9. doug Avatar
    doug

    And one wonders what the point of a watch alarm sound would be in any case if it can’t be heard. But I digress…

    Like

  10. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    It is all very strange, isn’t it!

    Like

Leave a comment