La-opera-lohengrin * Notes *
Yesterday’s matinée performance of Lohengrin opened at Los Angeles Opera was the second of six. The new production, designed by Dirk Hofacker and directed by Lydia Steier, is exceedingly silly. The set is on a turntable and appears to be set amidst German ruins in a Prussian army camp. One especially enjoyed the fact that the swan that brings Lohengrin is a bed covered tent (pictured left with Soile Isokoski and Ben Heppner, photograph by Robert Millard). The choreography was not well-motivated and perhaps merely served the set, which was rotated at various points. At times it seemed that people rushed aimlessly around the stage and ended up at their marks too early.

Maestro Conlon kept the music going at a good pace. For the most part the woodwinds sounded pretty. The brass make a few mistakes, especially in Act II, but managed to be effective. The chorus was lovely, though again, as with Rigoletto, there were a few times when synchronization was a problem. “Treulich geführt” came off beautifully, sounding clear and together.

There were many familiar faces in the cast. Robert MacNeil and Greg Fedderly were the First and Second Noblemen, while Domingo-Thornton Young Artists Matthew Anchel and Museop Kim were the Third and Fourth. Baritone Eike Wilm Schulte was the Herald. All sang nicely.

Most of the principal singers were impressive. Dolora Zajick made for the perfect Ortrud, she sang with strength, richness, and with appropriate haughtiness. James Johnson played a tormented Friedrich von Telramund, his voice too is robust. Kristinn Sigmundsson sounded noble as King Heinrich.

Soile Isokoski gleamed as Elsa, and sounded particularly sublime in “Einsam in trüben Tage.” Some of her lower notes in Act II were not as lucid as her high ones. In the title role, Ben Heppner struggled. From the start the production did not make him seem heroic. When he emerged from the tent he hardly cut a fine figure, as his coat was unbuttoned, which was not a flattering look. If Heppner was in good voice, this would not have mattered, but unfortunately this was not the case. He had a few good moments, his voice has a warmth to it, and volume. However, he wailed his way up to high notes that were strained and rough. It was painful to hear him hail Elsa in Act II and he even cracked badly in the last act.

* Tattling * 
Nearly every type of unpleasant behavior was on display from the audience members in Balcony B. The couple in K 40 and 41 talked nearly every time a soloist was not singing, so even during the famous Bridal March. The woman in L 37 unwrapped cough drops and incessantly scratched herself during Act I, but had the good sense to leave, as she clearly was not feeling well. Someone in Row M tapped her stiletto heels against the concrete floor distractedly, while someone else in Row L quietly sang along. A mobile phone rang during Act II, but it was on so low that he or she did not even hear it, and did not turn it off. There was periodic beeping, perhaps from a recording device. Flash photographs were taken during the ovation. The worst offender was a person at the back of the house with a very loud phone, which rang at the end of the opera on four separate occasions.

Posted in , , , ,

12 responses to “LA Opera’s Lohengrin”

  1. John Marcher Avatar

    The audience for LA Opera can be the most dreadful of all- especially the matinee people. When I saw a matinee of Die Walkure last year a woman in the audience was eating a sandwich and talking to her husband between bites. My favorite however remains the woman seated in front of me during “The Fly,” who broke out binoculars to get a clearer understanding of David Okulitch’s manhood- from the sixth row of the orchestra.

    Like

  2. Sarah Avatar
    Sarah

    I always hear the same thing about Heppner.

    Like

  3. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    The worst audience I’ve experienced was in Lausanne. LA Opera’s audience is sometimes well-behaved. The audience for Rigoletto the evening before this Lohengrin was rather quiet. I was particularly confused because often the audience for Wagner is more serious and studious.

    Like

  4. Robin Avatar
    Robin

    I was surprised to see that Heppner has gained back all of that weight (and more)….. sad because it really affects his voice…. I remember his “Lohengrin” here…and the voice cracked dreadfully. Then, years later, saw him as “Tristan” at the Met – he had slimmed down and the voice was wonderful. Brava to Dolora! I felt she would be a great Ortrud!!! The production does look silly… and the Audience…..Mein Gott!!!! You showed great restraint!
    Thank you for the review….. I always love to read the “OT” take on productions.
    Ms. Mattila was stunning last night…some great final night improvs going on – it only added to the drama!
    ♥ Robin ♥

    Like

  5. y2k Avatar
    y2k

    I am appalled by the behavior of the LA Opera audience. It seems that’s the norm for the LA crowd based on your reviews over the years.
    I must say, the LA audience seems worse than the Dallas Opera goers… I never had a good (audience) experience there, and after my most recent trip last month, I swear I’ll never attend another Dallas Opera performance again. Ever!

    Like

  6. Unbiased Opinionator Avatar
    Unbiased Opinionator

    Mr. Heppner seems to have the same difficulties he had in the last Met Lohengrin, including serious problems with the top. This has been chalked up for a long time to the result of poorly treated diabetes, but one begins to wonder after four years. For those who remember him in his prime, his current vocal state is very sad.

    Like

  7. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    It was embarrassing. I was also not a paragon of good behavior as the Zeltschwan made me laugh.
    So glad to hear Makropulos was great!

    Like

  8. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Sometimes they are not too bad, just depends on what opera, what day, and so forth. The worst US audience I’ve encountered was in Seattle when the football team was doing well.
    That’s too bad about Dallas.

    Like

  9. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    It is quite regrettable.

    Like

  10. Hank Avatar
    Hank

    I glanced at LAOpera’s website and they have an “Opera Etiquette” link… guess it doesn’t get many ‘hits’.
    I can’t find on their website (maybe it’s because I haven’t yet had my 12th espresso) any mention of venue. Were these perfs done in the famous new Disney Hall?
    I don’t get to LA very often, but it is known to happen, and I’ve wanted to see a performance in the Disney venue ever since it opened, and it’s never happened.
    Bad audiences drive me crazy. Especially in Wagner. After this exchange, I’ll be sure not to attend LA Opera, no matter who’s singing.
    I still want to experience that Disney concert hall, though.

    Like

  11. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    LA Opera performs at the Music Center, in the Dorothy Chandler Pavilion (http://www.musiccenter.org/about/venue_dcp.html).
    Disney Hall is just south of the Dorothy Chandler. The audience for LA Phil is better behaved, as far as I can tell. The trouble about this venue is that everything seems equally loud. If someone opens a cough drop in the audience, you may still hear it even if you are quite far from this person.

    Like

Leave a reply to Sarah Cancel reply