Heart-of-a-soldier-act-ii * Notes * 
The world premiere of Heart of a Soldier (Act II pictured left, photograph by Cory Weaver) given by San Francisco Opera last night. The opera is about the life of Rick Rescorla, the director of security of Morgan Stanley who lost his life as the in the September 11th attacks after evacuating 2,700 people from the World Trade Center. The first half of this ambitious work covers 28 years of Rescorla’s story, with five different scene changes spanning four continents. The act is only an hour long, so it is great deal of narrative jammed into a tiny space. Basically, this means a lot of recitative and the need for quick scene changes. Librettist Donna Di Novelli’s words seem to take precedence over composer Christopher Theofanidis’ music. The second half deals with Rescorla’s last three years in New Jersey and New York. Here the ensembles, duets, and arias are less burdened by having to tell the story. The ending was particularly strong.

Director Francesca Zambello’s style suits this opera, as the characters are of course very human, being based on real events of recent memory. The set, designed by Peter J. Davison, has some movement, but is transformed by Mark McCullough’s lighting and S. Katy Tucker’s projections. The result was mostly a success, though sometimes the layering seemed overwrought. Also, having the towers so far upstage was a challenge for some of the singers. The choreography seemed natural, everyone moved nicely and with ease.

Maestro Patrick Summers had the orchestra sounding clear and flowing. The chorus sounded together and robust. The rest of the cast boasted many fine singers. Michael Sumuel (Ted, Tom) sang with warmth and nuance. Nadine Sierra was plaintive as Juliet. Melody Moore was convincing as Susan Rescorla, her voice clear-toned and arresting. William Burden too was persuasive as Rescorla’s best friend, his duets with Thomas Hampson (Rick Rescorla) were quite beautiful. Hampson sang enthusiastically, and his charismatic presence is commanding.

* Tattling * 
The evening began with “The Star-Spangled Banner,” and a fluttering American flag was projected on the scrim. The audience was impressively quiet, there was no late seating on the orchestra level, and almost no whispering.

Posted in , , , , ,

13 responses to “Heart of a Soldier World Premiere”

  1. Humble spectator Avatar
    Humble spectator

    Such a tragic and wonderful story… It’s a pity it lost a lot of its momentum for those of us in Balcony circle and above. In the final scene Rick disappeared under the curtain. For us in the second row his legs were visible, but I bet those above us didn’t even get to see that. We missed those last moments in which he is still directing the evacuation until the towers finally crumble down.

    Like

  2. JSC-SF Avatar
    JSC-SF

    I enjoyed it for the most part. It was also nice to spot Susan Rescorla, Christopher Theofanidis, and Francesca Zambello in the audience. I do agree that some of the projections were just too much.
    I was especially moved by the scene with the firefighters rushing into and up the stairs of the twin towers as the office paper was flying down all around. When they collapsed in their spots on each floor as the dark scrim came down – I took that as symbolizing the collapse of the towers. It was a very compelling and memorable effect.

    Like

  3. Hank Avatar
    Hank

    I was not there, not will I be seeing this one.
    What was the music itself like?
    Hank

    Like

  4. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    It’s a shame that where the sound is best in the opera house, the view is often cut off in such a way.

    Like

  5. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    That last scene was strongest, but it seems to me that this opera was awfully ambitious.

    Like

  6. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Even though I knew the story, I found myself spending more time trying to absorb the narrative than being compelled by the music, which was inoffensive and pretty. Going to give this one another go in the balcony for the sound.

    Like

  7. Lilacrobin Avatar
    Lilacrobin

    I have been at every stage rehearsal for two weeks plus the Final and Opening….guess you could say I am smitten with this powerful opera and how hard everyone in the cast, orchestra, and especially Cesca, Patrick and Cris worked to put those finishing touches on it. I will never forget Hampson standing on stage about a week ago, paper in hand, learning the words to a just changed aria (his big one near the end of ACT II)…. he is a consumate professional. I was really taken by how much everyone involved took this to heart and gave their all. After the first staged rehearsal, many of the Chorus were in tears, William Burden and Melody Moore, still kneeling, just hugged each other and sobbed. It is ambitious – but definitely a story that needed to be told. Musically, I love it…there are many melodic moments – “Train Your Heart” and “Juliet” just to name two…. the staging was impressive…the bagpipes at the end…a fitting touch to a real hero. Bravo to all involved! (Including Koa, the Golden Retriever!) See you tomorrow!
    ♥ Robin ♥

    Like

  8. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Wow, Robin, you really are dedicated! I was very impressed by the quality of singing in this, but couldn’t really get my brain around the music. At first blush, it was not my favorite new opera, but not my least favorite either. Look forward to seeing you tomorrow!

    Like

  9. Lilacrobin Avatar
    Lilacrobin

    Dedicated…..no…but impressed and insprired….yes…. I loved the music….and not just because I have now seen it several times….I came out of the first piano staging humming several arias…. to me, this a major truimph for a new opera…it doesn’t happen often for these ears….
    Mounting this production took great courage – on all parts.
    Hugs,
    ♥ Robin ♥
    p.s. Isn’t Koa (aka Buddy) wonderful?

    Like

  10. Jeff Avatar
    Jeff

    The music was fairly nondescript, almost like a movie sound track. The singing was not particularly memorable either, except for the love duet in the second act and the conclusion. It excelled as a drama, but the music did not excite me.

    Like

  11. Hank Avatar
    Hank

    If I’d KNOWN there was a Golden Retriever in the cast I would’ve made a point of seeing this one!
    h

    Like

  12. sfmike Avatar

    The golden retriever missed his first cue on opening night. Just saying.

    Like

  13. CruzSF Avatar
    CruzSF

    LOL. But the Golden Retriever got much applause on Sep 13.

    Like

Leave a comment