12_Orpheus_eb_140

* Notes * 
Orphée et Eurydice (William Burden as Orphée with the Furies pictured left, photograph by Elise Bakketun) opened at Seattle Opera on last night. Jose Maria Condemi's production provided a series of entertaining moments that did not quite cohere, but did not get in the way of the music. Phillip Lienau's set is clean, and the scene changes were smooth and quiet, enhanced by Connie Yun's lighting. The costumes, from Heidi Zamora, had a loose, relaxed look. Yannis Adoniou's choreography was dull, for example, the first ballet consisted of three dancers falling to the floor in unison and the third one was a pantomime foreshadowing the plot. The second ballet was silliest, the 7 dancers were Furies who drew their shirts over their heads. It seemed an untoward combination of Martha Graham's Lamentation (1930) and Merce Cunningham's Antic Meet (1958).

Conductor Gary Thor Wedow kept the orchestra moving, occasionally a bit a head of the singers. There were 2 or 3 minor intonation errors, but for the most part the orchestra had a nice, clear sound. The chorus sang well.

The principals were uniformly strong. Julianne Gearhart looked like she was on her way to Black Rock City as an Amore outfitted with pink ruffles, fairy wings, tall shiny boots, and a glittering cruiser. Her voice has a breathless, girlish quality to it. Davinia Rodríguez's voice is more piercing, and her Eurydice was convincing. Rodríguez pushed a little hard on some of the high notes at the beginning of Act II, Scene 2, but otherwise sounded fine. William Burden made for an incredible Orphée. His voice is sweet and bright, and his singing was quite moving. His "J'ai perdu mon Eurydice" was exquisite.

* Tattling * 
Someone unwrapped something in cellophane during the overture. There was some whispering, particularly when no one was singing. No electronic noise was noted. I laughed a great deal during the second ballet, and tried to keep this as silent as possible.

Posted in , , ,

15 responses to “Orphée et Eurydice at Seattle Opera”

  1. Kgg Avatar
    Kgg

    Ballet in opera ia almost always silly. Why is that? I love ballet!

    Like

  2. Lilacrobin Avatar
    Lilacrobin

    Love, love Bill Burden! What a sweet, moving voice he has! Great review! (And I smiled to visualise you TRYING to giggle in silence!!)
    ♥ Robin ♥

    Like

  3. JonathanN Avatar

    I enjoyed reading your blog. I see you offer priceless info. Will definitely come back for more of this.

    Like

  4. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Sometimes dance can enhance an opera, and other times it just is distracting.

    Like

  5. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    It was great to hear Burden in one of my favorite operas.
    Thanks, Robin.

    Like

  6. Professional Avatar
    Professional

    i did read some of your other writings ( I will not call a review what you write ) but i think you have some issues with the art form and you get satisfaction by being a beater. Is not what you see but what is behind it that is very concerning! I was there for the opening night and i have a very different picture as to what happen. And it was not any ballet, please get educated…the choreography was post modern dance and very appropriate to the story.

    Like

  7. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Which art form? Dance? Probably. I studied 3 years of Graham-based technique at university, so I would imagine I’m pretty biased about contemporary dance. To be clear, I didn’t think the technique of the dancers was lacking. I just found the choreography unoriginal.
    Orphée et Eurydice is one of my favorites. In the score the pieces for dance are all labeled as ballets, as the opera is from 1762. I thought it was musically quite satisfying, one of the best performances I have heard at Seattle Opera, so I’m not sure what you mean by “being a beater.”

    Like

  8. Professional Avatar
    Professional

    sorry but you are so wrong!!!

    Like

  9. Professional Avatar
    Professional

    Condemi’s work is truthful and he is a great director that brings great breath to the Opera as he did here for Orfee! and your comment here is very shallow: “Jose Maria Condemi’s production provided a series of entertaining moments that did not quite cohere, but did not get in the way of the music.”
    You think the choreography was “unoriginal”! I am sorry but the choreography looked nothing like Graham and by the way the stretch fabric is been used so beyond Graham.
    Now even more sad that you study dance and you write so negative about it before you even try to understand it.

    Like

  10. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    While I think it is wonderful that you loved this performance so much, we just had a very different experience of the piece, it seems.
    I’ve seen a lot of Condemi’s work, and for some reason it doesn’t speak to me. I thought perhaps it was because he did a lot of revivals since he is rather young, but I just wasn’t impressed by this Orphée et Eurydice. Maybe because I love this opera so much and I don’t need it to be brought alive for me, I already find it very moving, beautiful, and vital. I don’t see why this is shallow. I do my best to read literature, study scores, and go to as many performances as I can.
    Compared to Mark Morris or Pina Bausch, no I don’t find this choreography original. And you are right, it didn’t really look like Graham either. I don’t want to have to “try to understand” art, I feel it should move me or not, and this choreography, at best, only made me laugh.

    Like

  11. nixietube@yahoo.com Avatar
    nixietube@yahoo.com

    Dear Professional,
    I love you.
    Sincerely,
    Opernphrenologe

    Like

  12. Professional Avatar
    Professional

    Please stop comparing and dropping names, every artists has its own path and this is what you need to be looking and talking about. It is not what you want to see but what artists are saying!!!
    The director has the responsibility to move the art forward as well to respect its past and true. Now i do not know how you said that choreography made you laugh ( at least this is better then “dull” ) i thought and the people around me that it was moving. The dancers fall down the hill was one of the best ways to showcase grief and the Elysian fields was so well done and moving. Thanks for listening!

    Like

  13. Thank You Avatar
    Thank You

    Tattler – I believe you describe this performance more accurately than any of the other reviews I’ve read. I watched the performance with a group of professional and student dancers (most in ballet but one with a college degree in modern dance) and we were all giggling as quietly as possible. The choreography really was funny. It reminded me of the last “flash mob” I witnessed more than anything else. We all sincerely loved the show, the singing was especially beautiful, but there were many silly aspects in the lyrics, dancing, set and costuming that I could have sworn were intentional but no other review has mentioned a thing about laughter! Thank you for your honest review. I don’t think you are being hateful at all.

    Like

  14. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Comparisons are odious, but given that both Morris and Bausch created important productions of this opera, I don’t really feel I can just set that aside.
    That’s just it, I don’t know what it was that the director or choreographer were saying, for some reason the whole thing just didn’t hang together in an interesting or intentional way (for me). I would have hardly flown to Seattle just to trash this production, I very much wanted to like it. In the end, I did like it very much, but more for the musical values.
    Again, that’s wonderful that this production moved you so much. One of the great things about art is that it can elicit different feelings from different people.

    Like

  15. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Thanks for your comments. I don’t think I’m likely to forget this performance soon, so I think it was a success in that respect.

    Like

Leave a comment