Merola-grand-finale-2012* Notes *
Last night’s Merola Grand Finale featured many fine tenors. Casey Candebat sang a sweet “Pourquoi me réveiller?” in the first half of the program, and applause interrupted his scene with Sarah Mesko as Charlotte. Theo Lebow sang a pretty “O blonde Cérès” (from Les Troyens) but some of his high notes were a little raveled. AJ Gluekert was strong in Samuel Barber’s “At last I’ve found you.” Chuanyue Wang may have lacked a certain ease with “Povero Ernesto… Cercherò lontana terra,” but has a lovely voice.

There were a few standouts among the sopranos also. Suzanne Rigden had a beautiful lucidity as a rebuffed ghost in Lully’s Alceste (pictured above, photograph by Kristen Loken) and sang Zdenka in “Ich danke Fräulein…Aber der Richtige” with characteristic flexibility. Jennifer Cherest had a charming duet with Andrew Stenson from Die lustige Witwe, both had fairly clear diction and sang with appeal. The audience loved Elizabeth Baldwin’s selection from Il corsaro.

Many of the singers are impressively adept at acting. This was especially on display in “Orsù, la tua nipote…Pappataci! Che mai sento!” with Joshua Baum as Lindoro, Seth Mease Carico as Mustafà, and Gordon Bintner as Taddeo. Rose Sawvel and Joseph Lattanzi had everyone laughing with “Il m’a semblé sur mon épaule” from Offenbach’s Orphée aux Enfers.

It is always of interest to hear how the singers have improved over the course of the summer. Andrew Kroes had a rich sound in “Volontiers, un vieil air Huguenots…Piff, paff” and was suitably sinister. Erin Johnson’s voice seemed more anchored as Juno in “Somnus awake!” than in her Schwabacher Concert.

Stage director Jennifer Williams used the set for Moby-Dick as her backdrop, with a few pieces of furniture strewn about. There was much throwing of flowers and dragging of cloth over the course of the evening. Williams seemed concerned with storytelling, and at times this worked, and at other times it felt a bit stilted.

Nicholas McGegan conducted the San Francisco Opera Orchestra in his particular jaunty style. The orchestra did occasionally get ahead of the singers in the first half of the program. Despite being a Baroque specialist, Maestro McGegan was convincing in most all of the different periods of music represented.

* Tattling *
A person in Row L Seat 6 texted for much of the overture from Béatrice et Bénédict that began the performance. She continued to look at her phone, but finally left after the fourth vocal selection.

Posted in

8 responses to “Merola Grand Finale 2012”

  1. Bitswizzler Avatar

    I was wondering where the set was from, and the rings at the front of the set looked nautical.

    Like

  2. Lilacrobin Avatar
    Lilacrobin

    Casey Candebat and Sarah Mesko were my favourites! They both has passionate voices – plus they acted!
    I was in Row J (for the 1st Half)and could see the tears in her eyes…(of course, I happen to adore Werther..so perhaps I was predjuiced)!
    I wasn’t very impressed with Lebow….because his acting seemed non-existent. AJ and Melinda were very strong in the Barber piece….AND…I could understand their English without looking at the titles.
    Love, loved Joshua Baum as Lindoro, Seth Mease Carico as Mustafà, and Gordon Bintner as Taddeo. Die lustige Witwe duet was lovely.
    I hadn’t heard any of the singers before…so was very impressed with Andrew Kroes…his was a chilling aria!
    My tatling – the young and very bored couple in Row I – spent the first half cuddling, kissing, she pulling her hair, moving up and down, back and forth…obviously BORED….I was hoping they would leave at Intermission – but – alas – no luck…so I moved a few rows back so I could have a clear, uninterrupted view!
    All in all, an enjoyable night….there’s hope for the future of Opera!
    Now….on to the Autumn Season!
    ♥ Robin ♥
    p.s. I guessed that set was part of Mody Dick!!!!

    Like

  3. Nadia Avatar
    Nadia

    You clearly are too kind to the singers! I think the tenor in “Orsù, la tua nipote…Pappataci! Che mai sento!” had a very rough voice, and sung quite unpleasantly. As well, as Seth Mease Carico – he has a strong voice, but he does not use it well, and thus, Don Giovanni did not sound right at all! Jennifer Cherest killed Alcina! And the bass in Alceste was terrible!

    Like

  4. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I was surprised to see this set again so soon.

    Like

  5. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Thanks for your thoughts, Robin!

    Like

  6. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Since Merola is a training program, I do go easy on the participants. Sometimes those that don’t impress me in Merola do improve a lot, and end up winning big competitions or debuting at the Met. Can’t disagree with most of your comments though.

    Like

  7. Sam Avatar
    Sam

    Speaking of training programs…the rumor around the Amici is that they will be making the Adler decisions tomorrow, with 6 openings.

    Like

  8. The Opera Tattler Avatar

Leave a comment