Merola-don-giovanni-2014* Notes *
Merola Opera Program‘s latest production of Don Giovanni (pictured left, photograph by Kristen Loken) opened with the first of two performances on Thursday night. Director James Darrah’s production goes against the text and the drama, with most of the action taking place in an artist’s studio, designed by Emily MacDonald and Cameron Mock. There is lots of face touching, crawling about, and getting up on tables. While enjoyably amusing, this does little to elucidate the narrative. I did laugh a lot when the chorus banged on the table in the last scene.

Admittedly, there are some effective devices and times when the space was used inventively. It is cute when Leperello walks out into the audience for the line “Anch’io, caro padrone, esibisco la mia protezione” and chooses someone to “protect.” Also, Don Giovanni’s descent to the netherworld is handled convincingly enough, with the chorus simply overwhelming him.

Martin Katz conducted a tentative and somewhat muddy sounding orchestra. The strings were problematic. Act II was an improvement over Act I, however. In any case, the impressive singing was certainly the main attraction, as it is for all Merola events. Yujin Kim and Rhys Lloyd Talbot made for a perfectly nice Zerlina and Masetto. Kim was particularly jaunty. Szymon Wach was a roguish but not especially lovable Leporello. His voice has a husky quality but is sufficiently loud. Scott Russell sang the Commendatore with power. Karen Chia-Ling Ho made for a strong Donna Elvira. She definitely seemed unhinged.

Benjamin Werley sang Don Ottavio’s two arias with great beauty, there were times when his voice truly seemed seamless. Amanda Woodbury (Donna Anna) has a bright, lovely voice. Her arias were some of the best moments of the evening. Edward Nelson has an attractive voice and radiated confidence as a rather unlikeable Don.

* Tattling *
The audience was fairly silent and still. A girl in E7 had to exit the hall in Act I but returned quickly. The most ill-behaved person I observed was myself, as I had difficulty containing my mirth at the production.

As we were leaving, I also got in the way of the director as he rushed out of the theater to take his bow on stage. While this was happening, we admired an adorable sleeping newborn in a young woman’s arms backstage, oblivious to the ovation.

Posted in , ,

8 responses to “Merola’s Don Giovanni”

  1. Karen Avatar
    Karen

    I thought the shift from a written to a visual “catalog” was quite smart. Don Giovanni as a character can be tricky, of course, since he needs to be caddish, but at the same time it must be believable that hundreds of women willingly go to bed with him. Presenting him as a sort of celebrity artist/photographer makes him someone who craves attention but also who can make his subjects feel beautiful—one of the ultimate turn-ons. Showing Donna Elvira drawings of his other conquests rather than just names in a book was very effective, and supported her portrayal of humiliated devastation. The pictures on the wall in back hinted at our current world where any indiscretion is likely to end up on Instagram or Facebook, and also suggested the obsession of a lepidopterist.
    I’ve been in love with this opera for a good 30 years, and I liked this production very much. Having seen it many dozens of times, I am delighted when a director offers valid new insights, which Darrah and his team certainly do. I’m even going to go see it again tomorrow.

    Like

  2. Karen Avatar
    Karen

    By the way, I just looked at your About page and it seems we would get along: I also have a linguistics degree, love Baroque opera, studied music as a child/young adult (piano and oboe), fear Wagner, and am constantly flabbergasted at the behavior of audiences at classical music performances. Were they raised in barns? Has no one in their lives ever cared enough about them to teach them how to behave in a theater? I use Facebook rather than a blog as my space to vent about it. I feel your pain.

    Like

  3. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Insightful observations, it is true, the psychological framing of Don Giovanni as artist makes sense, and the sketchbook as catalog worked well.
    This is also one of my favorite operas. I wish I hadn’t been so distracted by the strings. Basically they gave me a stomachache for the whole first half.

    Like

  4. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    It does sound like we would get along. Facebook is probably a more appropriate place to vent!

    Like

  5. David Lasson Avatar

    Speaking in general, and not having seen this production: Calling the Don “caddish” doesn’t quite get to the heart of his behavior, I fear. For one thing, caddishness is not usually thought to be a damnable offense; if it were, Hell would be populated largely by frat boys. And don’t forget that within the Don’s first few moments on stage, he commits what we call today felony murder–killing someone while in the commission of another crime (that other crime being either seduction or rape, depending on the director’s interpretation). Then, later, when the Don proclaims “Viva la liberta,” he fools no one, for it is clear that he confuses true liberty with being a libertine. In addition, he assaults both Masetto and Leporello. Considering the Don’s serious crimes, caddishness is one of his charming qualities.

    Like

  6. sfmike Avatar

    The adorable baby belonged to the production designers Emily MacDonald and Cameron Mock who recently married and had a child.

    Like

  7. Karen Avatar
    Karen

    Oh, certainly I agree. The guy’s a sociopathic serial rapist and murderer. Whether that is wholly apparent to the women who have succumbed to him (and want more, in at least some cases) is less clear. To many of them he may just seem like a cad/jerk/whatever. That’s more of what I was getting at: the audience has to believe that he was able to fill that catalog despite his generally observable behavior.

    Like

  8. Ruth Robertson Avatar
    Ruth Robertson

    Ha-Ha! Tattling on yourself…love it!

    Like

Leave a reply to Karen Cancel reply