Luisa-miller-lc-mf-2015* Notes * 
The 93rd season of San Francisco Opera opened Friday with Luisa Miller, a Verdi rarity only seen on the War Memorial stage a dozen times before. The opera has a quintessentially Verdian plot: a protective father, an innocent daughter, a secret identity, and a love triangle that ends in a protracted death scene. Part of Verdi's middle period, Luisa Miller does not have the lively tunes of Rigoletto, La Traviata, or Il Trovatore that followed soon after. But there was some beautiful singing in last night's performance.

The two leads (pictured above, photograph by Cory Weaver) were clearly strongest. Local favorite Leah Crocetto sang the title role without a hint of strain. Her pianissimi were gorgeous. Tenor Michael Fabiano is a dashing Rodolfo, and his voice is similarly attractive, very bright and pretty.

As Luisa's father, baritone Vitaliy Bilyy had a fine San Francisco Opera debut. Bilyy's voice has a pleasant weight, the right mixture of heft and lightness. Mezzo Ekaterina Semenchuk (Federica) also had a good first performance on the War Memorial stage, her dark tones contrasting nicely with Crocetto.

Daniel Sumegi wobbled as Count Walter, while Andrea Silvestrelli was a powerfully evil Wurm.

Maestro Nicola Luisotti conducted the orchestra with grace and as usual the woodwinds sounded great. The members of the chorus pulled together well.

Francesca Zambello's production, directed here by Laurie Feldman, involves background panels that make up a dreamy forest scene. The panels can move vertically and help change scenes. There is also a very weird beam crosswise above the stage that holds a large panel depicting various images, including a cottage and a hunting tapestry. This was less successful than the background panels, often it seemed awkward and in the way.

Ungainliness might have been inevitable for this opera, the plot is truly absurd and the final death scene was not convincing, despite the lovely singing.

* Tattling * 
I was shocked to be the first person in the standing room line when I arrived after 8am with my 1.5 year old in tow.

The remarks by San Francisco Opera's General Director, President, and Chairman of the Board were uncharacteristically brief and articulate. The audience was mild this year, and most of the extraneous noise heard during the performance came from the lobby after intermission.

Posted in , , ,

10 responses to “SF Opera’s Luisa Miller”

  1. Trixie of The Tea Drinker Avatar

    A very fine start to the season, by your detailed account, O Wondrous OT! Hooray!!

    Like

  2. Michael Strickland Avatar

    I sort of love that some of the society crowd decided not to watch any more of that boring old opera and kept partying in the lobby after intermission. It feels like tradition is being upheld.

    Like

  3. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Beautiful singing, indeed.

    Like

  4. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    Luisa Miller is certainly not my favorite Verdi opera. But it is nice to have a change of pace since I’ve never heard it before.

    Like

  5. William Smith Avatar
    William Smith

    I have a DVD of a 1977
    (?) Met performance with Scotto, Domingo and Milnes. I think the opera has a lot of beautiful music. “Quando le sere al placido” anyone? Especially when sung by Placido. 🙂 BTW, I think Luisa Miller qualifies as part of Verdi’s “early period” rather than middle period because it comes before Rigoletto. Perhaps it could be called “late early” period.

    Like

  6. Michael Strickland Avatar

    I love Verdi. I think it was Britten who included him as one of those rare composers whose music he so respected that even when he didn’t like a piece, he figured the problem was him as a listener. So hearing “Luisa Miller” should be a special treat, and what I heard of the music last night was wonderful. However, the production wasn’t bad so much as it was lackluster, and this kind of opera needs special care. It made me want to go home and listen to a great recording instead.

    Like

  7. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    No disputing the beautiful music in Luisa Miller, I only meant the arias are not as catchy as those of Verdi’s other more performed works.
    I suppose “late early” would do as well as the “early middle” I had in my mind when thinking about this work and its place in Verdi’s oeuvre. You are probably right! Thank you, as always, for your thoughtful comments, William.

    Like

  8. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I think I may well return to this with the score, but not terribly interested in seeing it again as far as this run goes.

    Like

  9. Roberto Avatar
    Roberto

    I had a great time yesterday. Very impressed with Leah Crocetto and Michael Fabiano. Specially Fabiano. His Rodolfo was on another level compared to the Puccini’s Rodolfo he sang here not too long ago. I can sense that these two singers are maturing and will soon become international sensations.
    I noticed a lot of Don Carlos on this opera. Not a coincidence since both are based on Schiller plays.
    Big thumps up. People shouldn’t miss it.

    Like

  10. The Opera Tattler Avatar

    I’m glad you liked it! The singing was really great, especially Fabiano’s.

    Like

Leave a comment